• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

IS this a sign of a dying harddrive?

ComatoseDelirium

Senior member
My harddrive isn't always recognized when I turn on the computer, it makes an odd doo-doo noise, when it doesn't work, although if I unplug the ide cable and put it back in it starts to work.. its a maxtor 60 gig. I am kinda in denial.. because I dont feel like getting a new harddrive and copying everything over.
 
Copy it at once if its data that you dont want to lose. The drive is most definately on its way to that big electronics heap in the sky.
 
This is what happened to a couple of my Maxtor drives.

Usually, they just die with no warnings at all. I have a 100% failure rate in Maxotr drives, one lasted two hours and it's replacement was DOA, it just made a really loud "CLICK" when powered up.

A coworker had tons of MP3 and video files on his PC. The boss and I put my clicker Maxtor in his PC and moved the cables off his HD onto the dead one. The look on his face when he turned it on and it just clicked was great!

No more Maxtor drives for me.
Never lost a WD..
 
Welcome to the forums, and yeah, it was used I got it cheap, and its lasted 3 years, i am planning to get a wd, my master is a wd, and so far.. awesome. Plus I hear they have a good warranty.. now.. how do i get money..? time to flip my parents over and shake them till its all good and dandy.
 
Originally posted by: RadiclDreamer
Copy it at once if its data that you dont want to lose. The drive is most definately on its way to that big electronics heap in the sky.

Its a Maxtor, I hardly think its going into the Heap in the Sky. 😛
 
Originally posted by: Bateluer
Originally posted by: RadiclDreamer
Copy it at once if its data that you dont want to lose. The drive is most definately on its way to that big electronics heap in the sky.

Its a Maxtor, I hardly think its going into the Heap in the Sky. 😛

Nah I had him baptized and he confessed that he loved Bill Gates as his personal saviour.. wait.. does that mean.. heaven or hell?
 
Originally posted by: hemiram
No more Maxtor drives for me.
Never lost a WD..

I have become very confused over WD, my friend swears he will never buy a WD hard drive again, because they keep failing on him. But all my experiences with WD have been excellent. And most people swear by them. I'm thinking maybe my friend just go unlucky.

 
I would run the utility that company has on it's website. They make utilities for their own products to test them out and every storage device company has some type of utility.
 
You can have bad experineces will all the manufactuers, i myself will never buy a WD because of my recent experience, personally right now i would go with a seagate and the 5 year warranty
 
Blue, Yeah that never occured to me.. I'll head to their site. Bow, that is a big selling feature of the seagates, I have only had one hdd problem in my short 15-year life, even though we have had like 8 computers, I think most of the information you hear is specific not general, I bet if they compared it, Maxtor would have just as many problems as WD, not to start a flame war or anything, I guess I'll just go with the company that has the best warranty, and seemingly best customer service. Service me Biatch.
 
Well, I had a string of Maxtor failures, one after another. The first was totally not the drives fault, it was 2 months old, and a car hit a telephone pole down the road, making the lights go out and back on about 4 times in the period of a few seconds, while I was writing to the drive and it started going sour almsot instantly. I went and bought a replacement Maxtor, and a decently sized APC UPS. I thought I would be ok, then a few months later, I got a BSOD, and when I rebooted it, I got the dreaded "drive not found" and the big "CLICK". I had sent the original HD back to Maxtor for replacement, and put it in, and it failed about 7 months later, but it was very slow in dying, it just clicked once in a while, and I was able to copy everything over to the new Maxtor drive, a replacement for the second drive. This one lasted two weeks. The replacement lasted 2 hours, then another replacement was DOA.

In the meantime, I had bought a 10 gig WD, that one still is in my old PC that a friend has now, and works fine.

MY old PC finally died, so I bought a Dell with a Maxtor, and 11 months later, it failed suddenly and without warning. The replacement 20 gig was a WD, and that drive today is in an external case and I use it to copy files over to friend's PCs. That PC survived a lightning hit that blew up my UPS, and took out the modem too. I was shocked when it booted up ok after I heard the UPS blow up!

I've never lost a Seagate or WD drive. My first Seagate, a 65 MEG RLL drive is STILL running over 16 years after I bought it. It came in my Packard Bell 286 that is alive and well running a friend's ham radio packet beacon 24/7. Everything in the case is original, except the sound card I added back in 1990. SOme PB stuff was great, as time went by though, it got more and more propritary and worthless.

If you were older, so you could drive, you could try this. Volunteer to take your little brother or sis to the store/school/whatever, or to go to the grocery store for mom. Mention you need gas money. If they give you a credit card, your'e out of luck, but if it's cash, just save a couple of bucks out of say 10 or so, and you will have the cash in no time. I financed several radio/stereo items this way over the years..
 
Never owned a Maxtor. I've owned a lot of WD drives, and RMAed a lot of them too. My latest rig sports a pair of Seagates. If they're confident enough to offer 5 year warranties on their drives in the current business climate, maybe they're really that solid.
 
A doo-doo noise?

Sorry bro, sounds this Hard disk is going to die soon 🙁. Happened to me the same way (sound and all). Do what people here are recommending, back up all your important data.

Look on the bright side, now you have an excuse to pick up that 72gb raptor 🙂.
 
HA thanks for the input guys Hemiram, nice way to skimp some change off a good deed 😉 Lol, But I came out straight to my mom, and said my hdd is dying I will need a replacement do you guys have any extra cash to help me out, they know computers being one of my passions will fund me something, but I have to wait a few days, I dont think this hdd will die for a few more months, right now im using it perfectly it will be a simple copy and paste job, although im searching.. and if their is a way I can get one of those fancy sata hdd, or one with a fast name.. like.. a cheetah.. or a raptor.. a falcon... not the lazy elephant, than I will. Anyways, if anyone is still reading this thread I do have a few questions I will ask and wait a bit, if no repsonses i'll just make a new thread.. or end up doing both, lol.


Will a satan drive work with my other standard WD 20 gig 7200 ATA drive? and Im thinking I might aswell move forward, I want to get nothing less that... an 8mb buffer 7200 RPM hdd, probably a sea gate cause of that tasty 5 year warranty.

if you have any recommendations, name it. 80 gigs and better than the one that just died. I got a HD diagnostic tool and will check out the hdds and post anything of interest.
 
Amp, yeah its queer, when I power on before it gets to the windows screen it makes one.. Doo- Doo, it reminds me of a noise I heard on startrek once.. some.. scanner or... 'transporter problem- like they have every 2 episodes.' yeah atleast I can get something better, a raptor might be out of my price range but we are going to staples for a printer so i will see what i can weasel my parents into getting me.. I might use the old standard.. you dont have to get me a b-day present excuse. But eh I dont ask for much the last thing they bought me 300 dollars for this computer in dec. im a rather content boy with my material possessions.
 
Originally posted by: ComatoseDelirium
Will a satan drive work with my other standard WD 20 gig 7200 ATA drive?

hehe, got a good laugh out of that one 🙂

anyways, unless your mb has a SATA port on it, you will be out of luck unless you get an SATA controller. I would definitely go Seagate, as WD, and Maxtor have worn out their welcome in all of my machines. You should be able to get a decent 120GB drive for ~$80, heck, I just saw a guy selling 2x120GB ATA hdd's for $120 shipped in the FS/FT section.
 
HEY HAHAHA, I just read my lil typo. Ahh Im canadian, and plus I told my parents like 50-60$, I think I might go for the 80 gig and save a few bucks, I was just looking at the Buyers Guide for storage, I think I will go with the Seagate U150 80GB 7200RPM 8MB Barracuda 7200.7 make it the master with the OS, and store all my other crap on it programs etc I have 15 gigs of audio/movies/porn that I will stick on my 20 gig. Thanks for the interest/posts.
 
Originally posted by: So
Originally posted by: ComatoseDelirium
My buffer size on these 2 drives is 2 megs.. isnt that.. like LAST generation, or is that still standard?


Just to give you and idea... Text

Ouch that stings, the hdd can be overlooked sometimes :\, I dont think I have the cash for a 16 Meg cache, but i'll aim to get an 8 meg one.
 
OH YEAH, is their anyway my maxtor could still be under warranty? :evil: it might just be under 3 years.. but it was bought used from a computer store.
 
Back
Top