Is it better to own retail or oem version of XP

thestain

Senior member
May 5, 2006
393
0
0
running into lots of adware and viruses that have caused no end of problems with computers among friends and family.

Half of us have Xp Home and the rest except one has Xp Pro.

All versions are OEM..

1) Is there some way to upgrade from oem ownership to a full retail license, apart from buying retail?

2) If you had to choose one retail version to support all.. would it be home, pro or MCE?

3) Any quick fixes when you encounter problems with Explorer or Media Player?

Thanks

The Stain:shocked:
 

Aluvus

Platinum Member
Apr 27, 2006
2,913
1
0
1. Not that I'm aware of. The only difference would be tech support from Microsoft, which I'm told is not especially valuable.

2. Depends. Home is cheaper and fine for most, Pro has some more features that are occasionally worthwhile, and MCE has Pro's features plus a few (but minus some others). If cost isn't a big deal, it would be between Pro and MCE depending on which features are needed. If you need to be able to join a domain, for instance, you want Pro even though MCE can be cajoled into doing it.

3. The quickest fix in my experience has been to install something else, but that's likely not what you want to hear. What kind of problems?
 

jadinolf

Lifer
Oct 12, 1999
20,952
3
81
I have only Home retail (upgrade version)...3 copies.

As I understand it, if you change motherboards you'll have problems activating because your activation is tied to the M/B.

Hopefully, I won't.
 

n0cmonkey

Elite Member
Jun 10, 2001
42,936
1
0
Originally posted by: jadinolf
I have only Home retail (upgrade version)...3 copies.

As I understand it, if you change motherboards you'll have problems activating because your activation is tied to the M/B.

Hopefully, I won't.

That's only for OEM. Retail copies don't have that limitation.
 

mechBgon

Super Moderator<br>Elite Member
Oct 31, 1999
30,699
1
0
WinXP Pro will have the longest support life, but also has the highest up-front cost. If you buy retail, you're entitled to re-use it on another computer if you remove it from the first one. If you buy OEM, you're not supposed to do that.

WinXP MCE is only available OEM, so that rules out the retail option.

Regarding your spyware/adware/virus problems, it sounds like you need some increased knowledge on computer security. Here are my suggestions:

1) make sure the computers are protected by firewalls. If you have broadband, then put a router between the modem and your computer(s). This keeps them from being directly molested by computers on the Internet. I'd also use the Windows Firewall on WindowsXP with Service Pack 2, no exceptions allowed unless you have a particular need for them. This helps keep your own computers from attacking eachother if one of them gets infected.

2) if you have wireless, enable WEP or WPA encryption so people who live nearby can't accidentally or deliberately connect their virus-bearing computer to your wireless network. If you have a wireless gateway/modem unit already, and will be adding a wireless-equipped router to it, then disable the wireless on the gateway/modem and encrypt the wireless on the router.

3) make sure the computers have Automagic Updates switched on in the Control Panel.

4) use a current-generation antivirus software. Not McAfee 6.5, not Norton 2001, not some other relic that you're too cheap to replace. There's a thread in the Software forum with links to some free ones if you can't afford pay-for stuff. Make sure to turn on all optional capabilities.

5) consider using Windows Defender beta 2, you can find a link to it on Microsoft's front page.

6) consider using Limited-class user accounts for daily-driver purposes like email, web browsing and instant messaging. Make a new user account (Control Panel > User Accounts) named Admin and leave that one as a Computer Administrator account, then switch your usual account to Limited. This is a huge deterrent to spyware, adware and many other forms of malware. Bust out the Admin account only when you need Admin powers for something, like installing a new printer & software.

7) USER TRAINING Teach people the concept that all that glitters is not gold. All the other measures are useless if people are determined to install Free Smilies For Your Email!! and Free Living Waterfall Screensaver!!! OMG! and all that other shiny bait that people fall for.


8) If any of the computers are new enough to feature hardware Data Execution Prevention, then it may help against some exploits. Fully enable it like this.


Sorry if that's not really addressing your questions, but maybe it addresses your problems.
 

jadinolf

Lifer
Oct 12, 1999
20,952
3
81
Originally posted by: n0cmonkey
Originally posted by: jadinolf
I have only Home retail (upgrade version)...3 copies.

As I understand it, if you change motherboards you'll have problems activating because your activation is tied to the M/B.

Hopefully, I won't.

That's only for OEM. Retail copies don't have that limitation.

I'm sorry, I didn't say it correctly. That's why I bought retail.