Several things I find questionable with the results posted by that gentleman on the thread, the chief being:
He ran his machine when room temp is 37C. That's 100 degrees Fahrenheit.
He then claims that the ambient case temp with the Zalman on is 39C-- Just 2 degrees Celsius above ambient room temp?? In an enclosed computer with a hot CPU and vid card??? Sounds kind of fishy to me.
The jury is still out on whether one is significantly better than the other (and I'm withholding judgment until I see a more rigorous test), but I wouldn't take that thread as gospel.