Investment tips?

Orsorum

Lifer
Dec 26, 2001
27,631
5
81
I'm looking at three long term goals... saving enough to eventually earn a small amount each month off interest ($500 or so), looking about 10 years down the horizon; saving for my kids' college fund ($500,000 or so), looking 30 years or so; and saving for retirement ($2,000,000 or so), looking about 40, 45 years out.

I'm trying to figure out the best way to organize each type of account - this is what I'm thinking -

retirement - Roth IRA Mutual Fund Account, focusing on income funds, more volatile funds (for now).
college fund - Non-IRA Mutual Fund Account, focusing on growth funds, less risk, but enough growth prospects to make it worthwhile over the next 30 years.
income - intermediate term - regular brokerage account, focusing on stability - bond funds, etc.

My main question is focusing on the Roth IRA mutual fund account... since it is so long term, I know I can play around more with regards to risk, etc. But I also want to make sure that I'm maximizing my capabilities. Mutual funds tend to lower risk a bit - if I really wanted to take charge of it, I'm thinking an IRA brokerage account might be a smarter idea, since I can customize it, and I have the potential for much greater returns, or I can just leave it in a money market.

Any ideas, suggestions, etc?
 

xuanman

Golden Member
Oct 5, 2002
1,417
0
0
The Motley Fool has great advice for beginning investors.

As for some of your ideas, I would generally suggest against money market funds b/c the interest rates on those are so low. I'm pretty sure most don't even offer higher rates than inflation.

Mutual funds can lower risk, but you should also be aware that there are some very risky mutual funds. Some of the more interesting investments are the ones that track the market indices. SPY tracks the S&P 500 whereas QQQ tracks Nasdaq.
 

Orsorum

Lifer
Dec 26, 2001
27,631
5
81
Originally posted by: xuanman
The Motley Fool has great advice for beginning investors.

As for some of your ideas, I would generally suggest against money market funds b/c the interest rates on those are so low. I'm pretty sure most don't even offer higher rates than inflation.

Mutual funds can lower risk, but you should also be aware that there are some very risky mutual funds. Some of the more interesting investments are the ones that track the market indices. SPY tracks the S&P 500 whereas QQQ tracks Nasdaq.

I was suggesting a money market towards the end of the investment period (maybe the last four or five years), if I absolutely need to money (to protect what I have left); if the market is doing well, I'll keep the money in the stocks/funds that I need to. I can also (towards the end) look for an inflation-indexed bond fund or something similar, that can at offer a safe investment that maintains my purchasing power.

Mutual funds can lower risk (in general), but they have associated costs (not much, but to be considered); index funds are nice, they offer very low costs while maintaining a return consistent with the index.

I'm not entirely sure what my strategy should be just yet. I suppose I could wait for another couple months to figure out what I want to do about the Roth IRA account, while still opening the brokerage acct. and the mutual fund acct. (for the earlier two goals).
 

DaveSimmons

Elite Member
Aug 12, 2001
40,730
670
126
For the college fund, you might be able to have it grow tax-deferred even with the Roth, but I just have vague memories of reading articles (no kids of my own yet).

A brokerage account is the most flexible choice for all three accounts. If you can start with a combined balance for all 3 accounts of at least $50K then Schwab is a good choice since they have a wide selection of funds including Vanguard and their house fund, as well as offering any stocks you might want to buy. Under $50K they'll hit you with a $30/quarter account fee, making a lower-tier company like eTrade more attractive ($5K combined balance to avoid fees).

Vanguard itself has some kind of brokerage now, which might be a better deal if you're planning to buy mostly Vanguard funds (you'll save on transaction fees).

Also, this would be a very good time to buy S&P500 and others since they're down from war jitters. Wait a few months and you'll miss the initial pop after the crisis is over (one way or another).
 

Orsorum

Lifer
Dec 26, 2001
27,631
5
81
I don't have a lot of money to work with (~20k, at most), but enough to get a portfolio going, maybe add $200 a month to it, plus any unexpected bonuses.

I'm going through USAA Federal Savings bank, a bank that my family has dealt with extensively in the past, low transaction costs and suchlike.

I was thinking about buying an index fund soon, but I wanted to see how much lower the market will go (even though I know market timing is generally a bad idea).

I may as well open a brokerage acct. tied to a Roth IRA to start the retirement account, and probably keep the mutual fund acct. and the regular brokerage acct. separate (~4500 init. investment total), add $100 or so each month to each.
 

amnesiac

Lifer
Oct 13, 1999
15,781
1
71
Do you want guaranteed income for life? Look into annuities - fixed if you want a lesser but guaranteed stream of income, and variable if you want potential for more growth.

They'll earn you less for your money than a mutual fund but keep in mind that at least the fixed annuties are *guaranteed* payouts for the rest of your life, and then some if you choose.

 

Orsorum

Lifer
Dec 26, 2001
27,631
5
81
Heh, I feel very stupid.

I can at least only have two accounts now, just a regular brokerage acct, and the Roth IRA brokerage acct. Woo hoo.

Annuities are nice, but for now... especially now, I'd be better off just putting the money into ING and earning money off of that. When interest rates go up eventually, I might consider it.
 

linuxboy

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
2,577
6
76
Originally posted by: Zakath15
I'm looking at three long term goals... saving enough to eventually earn a small amount each month off interest ($500 or so), looking about 10 years down the horizon; saving for my kids' college fund ($500,000 or so), looking 30 years or so; and saving for retirement ($2,000,000 or so), looking about 40, 45 years out.

I'm trying to figure out the best way to organize each type of account - this is what I'm thinking -

retirement - Roth IRA Mutual Fund Account, focusing on income funds, more volatile funds (for now).
college fund - Non-IRA Mutual Fund Account, focusing on growth funds, less risk, but enough growth prospects to make it worthwhile over the next 30 years.
income - intermediate term - regular brokerage account, focusing on stability - bond funds, etc.

My main question is focusing on the Roth IRA mutual fund account... since it is so long term, I know I can play around more with regards to risk, etc. But I also want to make sure that I'm maximizing my capabilities. Mutual funds tend to lower risk a bit - if I really wanted to take charge of it, I'm thinking an IRA brokerage account might be a smarter idea, since I can customize it, and I have the potential for much greater returns, or I can just leave it in a money market.

Any ideas, suggestions, etc?


Hey Nate.


Goal 1: $500 interest per month (is that in today's dollars or inflation adjusted? What assumptions do you want for inflation? It's averaged 5% almost over the past 30 years)

Oh a comment: you can't touch annuities before 59.5 just like a qualified plan else you are taxed on the gains.

Solution 1, invest in a 70/30 bond/equity strategy (using large cap companies or indexing the S&P 500. You can take more risk if you want but it's 10 years out so your call. What do you think the market will do?) later switching to a pure bond strategy that has high income. Now the trick here is how will you cover that money. Two possible solutions. An open account where you are taxed on the gains with a dividend/interest reinvestment or a Roth IRA. In a ROTH, you can take out your initial contributions without tax since it's post-tax money. So long as you don't touch the gains, you can have income and still use the ROTH at retirement.

Solution 2, similar to previous and using an IRA. Put money in it but instead of withdrawing money as needed, annuitize the IRA using section 72(t) of the IRA code. What that means is that you start taking regular, equal, periodic withdrawals until the money is depleted. BUT, the account still grows due to interest/capital gains so you receive payments. Note, that payments here can vary

Solution 3, straight open account in a brokerage investing in mutual funds/equities/bonds

Solution 4, one of those crazy MLM schemes where you send Pav *puts pinkie to mouth* ONE BILLION DOLLARS.

My current recommendation is solution 4. (Please note, this is not done in my professional capacity and purely as a joke, no liability is to be accepted for the aforementioned statement)



Goal 2: College fund (again, in future or current dollars. What college and what's your assumption for tuition increases?)

Solution 1: Section 529 plan. You (and family members) can sock away up to 11 grand per year into mutual funds, grows tax deferred, used for any qualified tuition expense, room/board. Until the EGTTRA act of 2001 sunsets in 2011 (unless Congress takes action), wiythdrawals will be tax free. But even if they're tax free, the tax deferred growth is to your advantage

Solution 2: Education IRA. Up to 3 K per year (increases with time), grows tax deferred and withdrawals are tax free for qualified educational expense.

Solution 3, open account using mutual funds/equities/bonds.

Those are the plans. The strategy? Long term out, should be more aggressive and invest in primarily euities focusing on mid cap companies.


Goal 3: retirement (present or future dollars?)

Since you want to retire past 59.5, a ROTH IRA works wonderfully for you. Tax deferred growth and tax free withdrawals. Can't go wrong. Also, depending on your income, you can get a tax credit this year for contributing. An awesome personal retirement option. Don't forget about employer plans too... Oh and investment strategy is aggressive, small, mid, large, foreign and domestic with a 85/15 equity/bond mix changing as you age.

Please don't use an open account for retirement. Just don't. It will eat away your money through taxes.

As for the actual funds, do your research. I like Wasatch, Franklin Templeton, American, Oppenheimer, AIM, MFS, Vanguard, and the small sector funds that kick the crap out of regular indices through short-selling.

You online? Early... prolly resting. Email/message me, we'll talk. Don't know what the world will do with all this turmoil. The stock market may not be the best solution, these are strange and different times.


Cheers ! :)
 

Michael

Elite member
Nov 19, 1999
5,435
234
106
Here's my tip for you - ATOT is a terrible place to get this type of advice.

Michael
 

Orsorum

Lifer
Dec 26, 2001
27,631
5
81
Originally posted by: Michael
Here's my tip for you - ATOT is a terrible place to get this type of advice.

Michael

Actually, it hasn't been too bad so far, and I'm avoiding adviser fees (for now, Dave and Pav may start charging me soon, :p)
 

BooneRebel

Platinum Member
Mar 22, 2001
2,229
0
0
Originally posted by: novon
Don't invest, the ship is sinking and there is no way back.
Yes. Don't buy when the market is down, wait for it to come back up.

Wait a minute. I thought it was buy low, sell high. Yeah, I'm pretty sure that's the way it works.

rolleye.gif
 

Orsorum

Lifer
Dec 26, 2001
27,631
5
81
Originally posted by: BooneRebel
Originally posted by: novon
Don't invest, the ship is sinking and there is no way back.
Yes. Don't buy when the market is down, wait for it to come back up.

Wait a minute. I thought it was buy low, sell high. Yeah, I'm pretty sure that's the way it works.

rolleye.gif

One of the three basic rules, :p.
 

wyvrn

Lifer
Feb 15, 2000
10,074
0
0
I agree, this is not the best place for financial advice though a few financial advisors hang out here. My basic schpiel:

The basic things you want to be aware of:

  • reduce your tax liability as much as you can
  • invest in low load or no-load funds
  • balance risk vs. return
  • diversify, ie: don't put all money into one fund type
  • research before you invest
  • don't move your money around too much, this destroys potential value and you pay fees to do it

Another vehicle is real estate. I currently have a rental property that pays for itself with a tad left over every month, and in less than 10 years it will be paid off. I will be 38, with an extra $1250 or so a month in disposable income, not to mention the appreciated value of the property should I choose to sell. You can defer taxes on the sale of real estate by moving that money into a bigger property with a certain amount of time. It is a good way to avoid gains tax and pass wealth on to your children. I don't spend a lot of time managing it either, since I screened my renters. I suggest reading the book The Only Investment Guide You'll Ever Need, avail. at Amazon or your local library (that's where I found mine). Also, morningstar.com is a great website for research. The biggest mistake you can make is not investing or investing poorly without proper research.
 

Orsorum

Lifer
Dec 26, 2001
27,631
5
81
Originally posted by: wyvrn

Another vehicle is real estate. I currently have a rental property that pays for itself with a tad left over every month, and in less than 10 years it will be paid off. I will be 38, with an extra $1250 or so a month in disposable income, not to mention the appreciated value of the property should I choose to sell. You can defer taxes on the sale of real estate by moving that money into a bigger property with a certain amount of time. It is a good way to avoid gains tax and pass wealth on to your children. I don't spend a lot of time managing it either, since I screened my renters. I suggest reading the book The Only Investment Guide You'll Ever Need, avail. at Amazon or your local library (that's where I found mine). Also, morningstar.com is a great website for research. The biggest mistake you can make is not investing or investing poorly without proper research.

I wish I have the money for a real estate purchase... :(