Into the Wild - good, but HUGE plot holes

SaltyNuts

Platinum Member
May 1, 2001
2,398
277
126
Anyone see this? Pretty darned good. And beautiful shots of the wilderness. However, it had some massive plot holes.

For one, the kid gives all his life savings to charity, and burns whatever cash he had left on hand. Has nothing. But then all of a sudden he shows up with a kayak to kayak down the river (where there is allegedly a 10ish year waiting list to be able to paddle down it, wtf that was stupid), without the movie showing a single indication of how he came up with it.

Same thing with the gun. Although by that time he had gotten a job, so I guess he could have used money from the job to buy it. But they didn't show it.

The the ending. He's ready to go home, but can't, because he can't get across a moderately-fast flowing river? Really? He had braved all sorts of stuff, but couldn't just swim it? Or walk upstream or downstream a bit to try and find a better place? Instead he goes back to his broke-down bus and spends weeks (months) more there when he is clearly starving? So silly.

Them him eating the berried is even worse. If he ate bad berries, one of three things can logically happen. He could die. He could slowly get better. He could throw up to get them out of his system, then slowly get better. But he just kept getting worse and worse, even though he had learned not to eat the berries. Made no sense.

Actually, thinking about all this, it was a pretty silly movie. Looked great, but just made no sense too many times.
 

deadlyapp

Diamond Member
Apr 25, 2004
6,671
744
126
What? Are you dense? He gets the big check for working the fields, which is how he buys the kayak. He paddles the river illegally which is why the river patrol is chasing him in a later scene. As you say, he has already had a job by the time he gets to Alaska and presumably has some money left. Also he sells books and stuff at the weird tent city place and probably makes some there.

Did you not pay attention to the method of dying from the berries? It essentially makes it so you can no longer digest and you end up dying of starvation, which is basically what he did. No idea if throwing up would have saved him, perhaps he had already digested them too much to do any good (he did fall asleep).

Anyways, it's a freaking movie.
 

NuclearNed

Raconteur
May 18, 2001
7,882
380
126
synopsis: Romanticized version of "dumbass kid goes on a journey to find enlightenment but dies badly because he's a dumbass kid"