• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Interesting story on Slashdot about recent college graduates

Chaotic42

Lifer

-
SpuriousLogic writes
"I work as a senior software engineer, and a fair amount of my time is spent interviewing new developers. I have seen a growing trend of what I would call 'TV reality' college graduates ? kids who graduated school in the last few years and seem to have a view of the workplace that is very much fashioned by TV programs, where 22-year-olds lead billion-dollar corporate mergers in Paris and jet around the world.

Several years ago I worked at a company that did customization for the software they sold. It was not full-on consultant work, but some aspects of it were 'consulting light,' and did involve travel, some overseas. Almost every college graduate I interviewed fully expected to be sent overseas on their first assignment. They were very disappointed when told they were most likely to end up in places like Decater, IL and Cedar Rapids, IA, as only the most senior people fly overseas, because of the cost.

Additionally, I see people in this age bracket expecting almost constant rewards. One new hire told me that he thought he had a good chance at an award because he had taught himself Enterprise Java Beans. When told that learning new tech is an expected part of being a developer, he argued that he had learned it by himself, and that made it different.

So today I see an article about the growing narcissism of students, and I want to ask this community: are you seeing the sorts of 'crashing down to Earth' expectations of college grads described here? Is working with this age bracket more challenging than others? Do they produce work that is above or below your expectations of a recent college grad?"
-

Link

I thought it was an interesting little commentary and article. I was actually talking about this with a coworker not too long ago. At a couple of months from 27, I'm kind of in between being a fresh kid and a working middle-ager. I've been with my company for about five years and I've seen a few people like this.

We had one guy who was about my age, but fresh out of school. He kept coming in late on meeting days and finally the manager asked him to try and be on time. He said that he was embarassed and offended. Later, when someone was going over his work with him, he said he was again embarassed for having his mistakes pointed out in private. He often complained that having to work his eight-hour shift was like being in a sweat shop. He finally quit; I don't know if he had another job or not.

Anyway, I thought this might be something for everyone to read. Obviously not every recent graduate is like this, but it's important to remember that no one is really impressed with your degree, and if you can't do simple things like read and understand documents, ask relevant questions, and admit mistakes, you're going to be outcast if not fired.

The questions thing is important. I've had to point that out to several new employees. I told them that we all knew that they didn't understand everything 100% as that was impossible, especially three days into the job, and that they look silly by not asking questions. It worked. 😛

Anyone have any experiences to share? I only have an Assosiate's Degree from a backwater school, so I'm probably not qualified to discuss education and work experience with some of you. 😉


 
I agree, it's why girls in our society are so fucked up. They constantly see grey's anatomy type shit and never realize it's complete horse shit.
 
Originally posted by: MrMatt
I agree, it's why girls in our society are so fucked up. They constantly see grey's anatomy type shit and never realize it's complete horse shit.

I don't think our expectations are that blown out of proportion.

My only complaint about my first internship was how mind-numblingly dull it was.
 
Crazy that people would actually have such high expectations for their first full time job.

When I started my first IT job I did not expect much more then a desk, phone, and PC. In fact I was quite surprised when I was given a pix and RSA appliance and my first task was to setup a VPN. That's when I realized how useless college was since we never even did anything having to do with VPNs or RSA, despite 2 years worth of Cisco. Did get it working mind you. Was a fun project.
 
Originally posted by: RedSquirrel
Crazy that people would actually have such high expectations for their first full time job.

When I started my first IT job I did not expect much more then a desk, phone, and PC. In fact I was quite surprised when I was given a pix and RSA appliance and my first task was to setup a VPN. That's when I realized how useless college was since we never even did anything having to do with VPNs or RSA, despite 2 years worth of Cisco. Did get it working mind you. Was a fun project.

Real world experience is huge. Even working on something small at home can give you a tremendous insight which college might not give, especially for IT/Programming jobs.
 
Originally posted by: Chaotic42
Originally posted by: RedSquirrel
Crazy that people would actually have such high expectations for their first full time job.

When I started my first IT job I did not expect much more then a desk, phone, and PC. In fact I was quite surprised when I was given a pix and RSA appliance and my first task was to setup a VPN. That's when I realized how useless college was since we never even did anything having to do with VPNs or RSA, despite 2 years worth of Cisco. Did get it working mind you. Was a fun project.

Real world experience is huge. Even working on something small at home can give you a tremendous insight which college might not give, especially for IT/Programming jobs.

This is true. I'd say 90% of what I know that is significant for work, I learned at home by messing with that kind of stuff. Really the only thing I learned from college is what high stress feels like, and how to deal with it, but I have yet to get such high stress so far after almost 2 years of work.
 
Originally posted by: TecHNooB
I don't think our expectations are that blown out of proportion.

My only complaint about my first internship was how mind-numblingly dull it was.

Do0d, do you even realize how unintentionally funny your second sentence is following right after your first?

 
This seems to be an ongoing problem. This type of issue has been posted on here numerous times in the past few years.

The workplace will self-regulate itself when it comes to these attitudes. Jackasses with attitudes like that will not survive in the typical workplace until
they learn to know their role. Sure it may take them a few years to learn it, but they will, and likely the hard way.
 
*gasp*
What's that? You mean that scripted "reality" shows on TV are not really representative of reality?

Dammit, and here I thought that if I went into engineering, I'd be realigning a dilithium matrix and tweaking the subspace inversion relays in the warp coils.



If they're using TV as their "guide," they deserve what they get when they find out what real reality is like.

 
I've always wondered about people like that. I had a classmate in college that had less than a 2.0 average but was expecting to get a nice job out of school. He just couldn't understand why no one would give him an interview.

I've only been working for 8 months out of college in engineering. I work each week until I have to leave (46 hours due to overtime), have one patent that just got filed, a second just got approved to be filed, and have been working my tail off to do my best. What do I get for it? A tiny little raise and I get to keep my job.
 
Originally posted by: RedSquirrel
When I started my first IT job I did not expect much more then a desk, phone, and PC.

That's all they gave me. :Q I didn't even have walls, except the one my desk was up against and a little divider between my desk and the communal printers.
 
Originally posted by: mugs
Originally posted by: RedSquirrel
When I started my first IT job I did not expect much more then a desk, phone, and PC.

That's all they gave me. :Q I didn't even have walls, except the one my desk was up against and a little divider between my desk and the communal printers.

you guys got desks and phones?

/jealous

I've been here for 5 and a half years and I won't actually have a direct phone line till I move into my new job/promotion next month.
 
I interview roughly 20 college studetns a year for full time hires.

Article is spot on!


It has gotten worse every year -we manage to find a few winners but we ultimatley end up termianting a high percetnage in the first two years. We fired our first one of our 2008 grads today for poor performance.


 
Originally posted by: loki8481
Originally posted by: mugs
Originally posted by: RedSquirrel
When I started my first IT job I did not expect much more then a desk, phone, and PC.

That's all they gave me. :Q I didn't even have walls, except the one my desk was up against and a little divider between my desk and the communal printers.

you guys got desks and phones?

/jealous

I've been here for 5 and a half years and I won't actually have a direct phone line till I move into my new job/promotion next month.

You guys got chairs!? In my day we had to stand on one leg, balance the PC on the other, hold the monitor in one hand while typing with the other . . . . uphill both ways!

I had an office at my first job, but it was a small company not an omnicorp.
 
I worked my ass off right out of college, have seen some moderate success, and fully expect to pay just as dearly the rest of my career to keep advancing at the rate I want to.
 
this is what happens when everyone gets a championship trophy at the end of the soccer season in 3rd grade.
 
The only thing that keeps me employed is that I am the only one around here that knows how to do my job. 😱 Otherwise I'd be so screwed 😉
 
Back
Top