• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Intel Xeon W3550 vs. Core i7 860

Mars999

Senior member
Hello, I know that the Xeon is for workstations, but what benefits do I get by using one vs. Core i7 series? IIRC the Xeon has ECC RAM and more accurate calculations? what about speed differences? Not only benchmarks, but just general feel when using the Xeon?
 
the xeon will not feel faster or benchmark faster unless you have a very memory-bandwidth specific scenario where the wider memory bus of X58 (compared to P55) will come through.

other than that, they are practically identical but architecturally the 860 has a new take on power management, they threw away the QPI hub give you fewer PCIe lanes on the north side. as a result of this the i7 860 and W3550 work on different sockets and are not interchangeable. The W3550 is more a sibling of the i7 920 than the 860.

X58 on the other hand gives you three memory channels instead of two, and a whole lot more PCI express connectivity. This is the preferred workstation platform because the idea is that you're running a lot of high performance peripheral devices and you need a way to connect.

the xeons support ECC but it isn't necessary for more "accurate" calculations in typical computing as the error rate is small enough that you would need a very large and time consuming workload for bit cell errors to corrupt your work. if you aren't running a server or doing any 72-hour render jobs, you really don't need ECC because it slows you down by a couple percent.
 
Back
Top