• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Input on switching to a CULV for everything but big games

hoorah

Senior member
Hey guys,

I've been leaning towards taking most of my stuff mobile and getting one myself, probably an ultraportable CULV, and using that as my main PC. For some strange reason, I really dislike having two pcs, I always spend so much more time and effort trying to keep things in sync and backing up files than I should. Everything I want is inevitably on the "other" computer. I'd like to keep all of my work, business, and personal files on the laptop. If it weren't for the games, I wouldn't be posting this, I'd just get the laptop and move on.

But, I do play games, not nearly as often as I used to though. On a regular basis, I play zombie panic source and L4D, but aside from that, I pick up a big title every once in awhile if its a series I've been following (HL, COD, etc), but not often. I can almost tolerate them on my wife's computer, but not quite.

My plan was to get a sweet spot of an ultraportable with decent graphics thats always rumored to be coming out, something like a dual core CULV with maybe an ION2 graphics card. By the numbers, that shouldn't have any trouble running the games I play daily, and then I wouldn't really need to worry about my desktop save for the few times I did play something that required the horsepower.

So after all that babbling, here's my question - has anyone found themselves in a similar situation and made the move to a laptop for non-intensive games and found it to be beneficial and simplified, or do you find it frustrating trying to game on a lower end laptop and always use your desktop at home, and use the laptop while away?

I think if I threw in the towel and gave up on the next half life ever coming out, I wouldn't even be posting this.
 
Oh, one more bit of info. My current desktop is a S939 4200+, 2GB DDR1, and an ati 4850. Yes, its mis-matched, I know. It still handles most games (with terribly long load times), but I don't complain.

Its getting to the point where I really need to think about upgrading the desktop, and I'm wondering if I should just put the money into the laptop instead and let the chips fall where they may as far as what settings I can run games on in the future. I'm definitely not interested in getting a boat-anchor of a gaming laptop, those things are huge.
 
I got a Wind U230 last friday, (Same guts as the AMD HP DM3, smaller package) and I have a 3ghz Phenom1 X2 desktop with a 4870, and 4gb DDR2. I'm still getting everything xfered over to my lappy, but it plays simple games pretty well (Civ4, WoW) and it's pleasant for web surfing on the go. The keyboard's great for me (big flat keys) and the touchpad is ok, if a little cramped. Battery life is OK if not great with 4-5 hours of web surfing, watching a movie, etc. or about 2 hours of time playing WoW. Personally I think that it's the best GAMING netbook out today, but of course you do make sacrifices for that.

Unfortunately I haven't really been using the netbook/Desktop combo long enough to make any real comments about the duo, but similar to when I had my ancient beast of a 10lb Athlon 3200+ laptop, I find myself gravitating to the desktop for significant gaming, video watching, some web surfing, etc. I find myself gravitating towards the laptop for IMs, light web surfing while watching TV, etc. (as well as doing everything while away from home base.) The big advantage of going to a laptop that's a third ths size for me was the fact that it is much easier to bring along with me, which means that I've got it in places where i wouldn't before, and I can also use it for much longer when I'm away from an outlet.
 
If you're not worried about turning eye-candy settings down if the game gets choppy, and if you'll accept the fact that eventually a newer game will come out that you want and simply won't be able to play, then go for it.

Make sure to get something with a discrete graphics card. I would say look into the ASUS UL30Vt-A1 or UL80Vt, or if you can hold out, see what the UL30Jt looks like - supposedly that will have a 3xx series Nvidia card (similar in specs to the current GT 220 or whatever it is), but more importantly, a CULV i3 or i5 to replace the current Core 2.
 
I got a Wind U230 last friday, (Same guts as the AMD HP DM3, smaller package)

Actually, I really liked the HP DM3 so far, but thought it was a bit on the underpowered side. Not so much that I wouldn't buy it, but that I'd rather wait to see what the next version brings. But then again, like I said, the games I play are ALMOST playable on my wife's laptop, so a decent improvement in graphics like the DM3 has (maybe 2x?) should be fine. Fine, that is, until I find a new game I like and then the cycle repeats.

I unfortunately find myself doing more and more work and playing fewer and fewer games, so I think using my laptop for everything but games on the desktop should work out okay. The only problem with that I see in the future is that if I'm only using the desktop for games, I will be less and less inclined to upgrade anything more than the video card, and will probably stop paying attention to it. Such is life, I suppose. Lots of toys to buy, not a lot of money.

I've always liked sticking to a delayed schedule for games - just play games from 3 years ago so your hardware is always fast enough and not worry about the new games, but wanting to find out what happens to Gordon Freeman always gets the better of me.
 
I've been wanting a smaller laptop for my personal use for a while now. The Alienware M11x is going to be it. It's pretty expensive but you really give up nothing except an extra 10-12 oz and $400. It can game, it can last 8 hours on battery, it's small, 4 lbs, 4GB of RAM, wireless and bluetooth, etc.
 
If you like HP DM3, newegg is selling SU4100 version for $489 after rebate and BCB

I took a look at that one on Newegg, but that one comes with the Intel 4500MHD, which is the same graphics my wife's laptop has in it (but she has a celeron 2.2). I don't know how a SU4100 compares with the single core celeron, but with the same graphics chip, I don't think thats going to cut it even for my casual gaming. I do admit though, as far as intel graphics are the 4500 is a great chip - it can even decode h.264 offloading from the CPU letting the laptop do 1080P blue-ray, which I've never seen an intel chip do before. Compared to the GMA950 that came in a laptop a year older than hers, its beyond fast. But I digress.

I guess the only way to get the DM3 with the HD3200 is with an AMD chip, which supposedly doesn't do as well heat/performance wise. Even still, the HD3200 onboard graphics would still be cutting it a little close. I think I will wait for the ION2 or similar graphics chip and then pull the trigger, or get something with a discrete card.

Part of me wishes I could just hit the button called "grow up" and stop playing games and make this whole situation easier, but I think we all know thats not going to happen 🙂
 
Back
Top