Incompatible Media, Or Faulty Drive?

yezhou

Senior member
Sep 13, 2004
269
0
0
OK, I have 2 DVD writers, one is a Lite-On SHW-1635SX and the other is another external from I/O Magic. The problem is with RW media.

First up, DVD+RW (Sony 4x):
----------------------
I got these Sony DVD+RWs, and basically the Lite-On can't write to it. It gives me an error each time I try, even with erasing it in Nero. HOWEVER, my I/O Magic reads/writes just fine with it. Now here's the weird part. If I write files to it with the I/O Magic, and put the disc in the Lite-On, it reads it fine! AND, if I now try to burn the disc, it works too!! What does this mean??
Oh yeah it writes fine with DVD-Rs (Taiyo Yuden). :Q:confused:

Second up, CD-RW (TDK 4x):
-----------------------
Basically, same sort of deal. If I try putting in media burned with my regular CD burner (Lite-On as well), it can't read it and basically locks up itself as well as my system, and I have to use a pin to "manually" eject the CD. The I/O Magic reads the discs just fine. Now if I erase the data with any other drive, the Lite-On will now read/write to it, same deal as with the DVD+RW discs. Weird??:confused:

So...does this mean the Lite-On is faulty? I bought it from NewEgg, and I've actually never had to deal with faulty merchandise with NewEgg before. What's the process of returning it? Regular RMA? Can I do a product exchange for another drive of equal or greater value? Thanks in advance.
 

psychotesis

Junior Member
Mar 22, 2006
12
0
0
Cheap drives don't burn on everything. If its an old drive, it just means that the laser is not burning as well and its time to change. If its a new drive, you just have to try media of other brand till you get a match. Typically, low quality media would create problems on an average or low quality drive. Although high quality media can burn on low quality drives, it might not have the best burn. High quality drives may burn low quality media, but the lens might not last as long as you'd like them to because the drive has to strain to get the data on right. High quality drives and high quality media make the best match.