Here's what I got out of it:
I thought Bush really stumbled, fumbled, and bumbled at the start, but did better as the debate went on.
I thought Gore seemed much more knowledgeable and Presidential, but maybe a little too prepared; as in trying to repeat the same key phrases over and over.
I thought Bush sounded more convincing on the education issue and though I'm not for privatization of Social Security, I believe he made points with those leaning that way.
I thought Gore won on the question of foreign policy. He just listed all his experience in the House and Senate and on the National Security Council, nothing for Bush there. I actually felt embarrassed for Bush when Gore "educated" him on the Russian position in Yugoslavia.
I also thought Gore sounded more credible on the Medicare and Social Security (like I said, I'm against privatization) issues.
I don't think either one of them has a real plan to deal with the energy problem. Gore's talk about new technology and energy sources sounds good, but I notice he didn't give any details. When Bush talks about more domestic exploration, all I hear him saying is, "Yes, here's a great chance to give all kinds of tax breaks and free land and reign to my big oil cronies". Also, what he said about an abundance of coal is absolutely ridiculous. He said he was just in West Virginia, well that state is expected to be completely out of mineable coal in 15 years.
Both of them got on my nerves at times. If Bush said "fuzzy math" one more time I was going to throw the remote at the screen. Gore asked twice for him to come right out and say that he was lying about figures and all Bush would say is, "there's that fuzzy math again".
Gore got on my nerves with his beating the "tax cut for the wealthiest 1%" to death. ALRIGHT ALREADY! I heard you the first 10 times!
Bush lost points with me when he attacked Gore personally at the end, but it also did remind me of a time that Gore acted quite Clintonish. I thought Gore did a good job of coming right back with saying he would sign the McCain bill and challenging Bush to say the same and Bush wouldn't, but overall that part just left me not liking either one of them for it.
I think that the people who were all for Bush before the debate will still be all for him, but they'll hope that he'll be a lot more prepared for the next one.
I think the people who were all for Gore before the debate will still be all for him and rightly think he looked better in this one, but they'll know that the next debate is in an entirely different format, informal discussion, and it may not suit Gore's style as well.
I'm still not sure who I'm voting for. I'm not particularly excited about either one. I plan to watch all the debates.