just remembered a good one... it's very contrived/constrained (as most riddles are), but is pretty good:
you are running a very dangerous nuclear experiment. you are trying out a new form of putty-like control rods that are supposed to be much cheaper and more effective, but they become ineffective after exactly ten minutes in water and must be replaced. you have two types of rods: rod A and rod B. you must toss into the water exactly one of each type of rod, every ten minutes, or the experiment overheats and you have a meltdown. the experiment will run for 100 minutes (so you have 10 of each type of rod), after which the uranium will be depleted and things are safe again.
the problem is that just as you started the experiment, your stupid lab assistant dropped the rods and they all got mixed up on the floor. and unfortunately, they all look alike, smell alike, weigh the same, taste the same and are pretty much indistinguishable! you have 10 minutes before the experiment gets going and you have to put in the first pair of rods to prevent a meltdown... and you have to put in exactly two of each rod every 10 minutes after that... put too few and you die... put too many, and you'll run out later and die... put in only one kind and you die...
what do you do??