A substitute teacher mentioned something in the faculty room about God punishing...
I didn't have anything to correct, so decided it was open season on her beliefs... "So, God is punishing the people in New Orleans? Weren't there a lot of innocent people there too?" "Yeah, but..."
5 minutes later in the conversation, and giving her time to forget that she agreed...
"Suppose the U.S., after 9/11, decided to just nuke Iraq and Afghanistan as punishment for what the terrorists did. Don't you think that would have been a better idea than going to war and losing a lot of American lives?"
"No, because a lot of innocent people would have died."
"So, harming innocent people is bad?" "Well, of course."
"Well, a couple minutes ago, you said that God punished the people in New Orleans, and that God has a plan, and that innocent people did get in the way. Are you saying that your God is bad? I don't know about you, but I believe in a superior God, one who is powerful enough that he can take on the bad people, and leave the good people alone."
She was absolutely flustered at this point
