Originally posted by: PrinceofWands
Originally posted by: jagec
Originally posted by: PrinceofWands
Based on the things he specifically is talking about, yes. It was a period of grotesque exploitation, rampant bigotry, sexism, elitism, etc. Yet he calls it the ideal time. If your ideal is those things, then it's the worst in human beings.
Having read a history book, I respectfully disagree with your assessment. I can think of many, many other periods of time that were far worse.
It's personal opinion of course. Being in school to become a history teacher I too have read a history book. In fact, I've read more than one. The real issue is that our criteria is likely different.
If your primary concern was black rights, you could consider the pre-civil war period as the worst. Then again, you could make an argument for early to mid twentieth century when there was supposed to be rights for blacks, but in fact there wasn't.
If your primary concern was religious intrusion into politics you could very easily focus on the early colonial, and second great awakening - but you could also argue a case for present day.
Personally I'm looking back at business exploitation of workers, class stratification, general human rights, broad bigotry, etc. 1880-1920 stands out in those areas to me. Mind you, I'm also keeping the focus on American history. Obviously I could look to other areas to see far worse examples based on pretty much any criteria (holocaust, inquisition, stalin, various genocides, etc).
It's true, I have a pet peeve about that period. I have issues with other periods too (especially red scare & McCartheism), but this one really gets my goat.