I witnessed a victory for the Express Lane at the store today

Chaotic42

Lifer
Jun 15, 2001
34,600
1,761
126
I went to the store after work today, probably some time around 9am. I bought 7 items and got in the express lane. Behind me, this woman with at least 60 cans of various petfood shows up. She says "These are 10 for $5, they count as one item". The cashier looks at her, tells her no, that's too many items, you need to get out of line and makes her leave.

Then the cashier looks at me and the dude behind me and says "I'm a mean b*tch. I don't let them get away with that."

It was all I could do to keep from busting out laughing.

Edit: Grammar
 

Queasy

Moderator<br>Console Gaming
Aug 24, 2001
31,796
2
0
I still argue with Wal-Mart cashiers about "20 items or less" not being an express lane...its more like a "leisurely pace" lane.
 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91
Hah... a few items over the limit is one thing, but I hate it when people act like they should be the exception to the rule, like their time is more important than the people behind them.

I was in a store once and saw a lady with a FULL cart of groceries go up to the express lane and say "I'm sorry, I'm in a hurry" and start unloading her cart. Yeah, and? Plan ahead better! She probably didn't need the FULL cart of groceries for whatever she was in a hurry to get to, and even if she did - plan ahead better!

I wish Costco would put in an express lane, but I know that doesn't make any sense for them. :D Maybe I need to get a bigger freezer.
 

Tom

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
13,293
1
76
but the woman may have been right. When a store sells "lots", which this might be, then a lot would be considered a singular item in many legal situations, which is what takes place at a register. It's a type of transaction that is governed by the legal system.

And if they were all the same, they wouldn't each have to be scanned.

 

Kelvrick

Lifer
Feb 14, 2001
18,422
5
81
Originally posted by: Tom
but the woman may have been right. When a store sells "lots", which this might be, then a lot would be considered a singular item in many legal situations, which is what takes place at a register. It's a type of transaction that is governed by the legal system.

And if they were all the same, they wouldn't each have to be scanned.

I would agree with you only if it was 6 cases of 10 cans each, so only 6 swipes of the barcode.
 
Jun 4, 2005
19,723
1
0
Originally posted by: Kelvrick
Originally posted by: Tom
but the woman may have been right. When a store sells "lots", which this might be, then a lot would be considered a singular item in many legal situations, which is what takes place at a register. It's a type of transaction that is governed by the legal system.

And if they were all the same, they wouldn't each have to be scanned.

I would agree with you only if it was 6 cases of 10 cans each, so only 6 swipes of the barcode.

You can multiply without re-scanning, but IMO, if you have to do that, then it counts as ++ item.
 

Chaotic42

Lifer
Jun 15, 2001
34,600
1,761
126
Originally posted by: Tom
but the woman may have been right. When a store sells "lots", which this might be, then a lot would be considered a singular item in many legal situations, which is what takes place at a register. It's a type of transaction that is governed by the legal system.

And if they were all the same, they wouldn't each have to be scanned.
The cashier said that each can counts as an item since it has to be scanned.
 

Tom

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
13,293
1
76
Originally posted by: Kelvrick
Originally posted by: Tom
but the woman may have been right. When a store sells "lots", which this might be, then a lot would be considered a singular item in many legal situations, which is what takes place at a register. It's a type of transaction that is governed by the legal system.

And if they were all the same, they wouldn't each have to be scanned.

I would agree with you only if it was 6 cases of 10 cans each, so only 6 swipes of the barcode.


It isn't a matter of agreeing with me, I didn't say she was right, I said she might have been right, according to the law.

I think it depends on the pricing, whether it would be considered a lot. If she had to buy 10 to get that price, then I would think it would be a lot.

 

ElFenix

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Mar 20, 2000
102,395
8,558
126
i think if you get in line with the correct number of items, items picked up while in line (candy) should not count against the total
 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91
Originally posted by: Tom
Originally posted by: Kelvrick
Originally posted by: Tom
but the woman may have been right. When a store sells "lots", which this might be, then a lot would be considered a singular item in many legal situations, which is what takes place at a register. It's a type of transaction that is governed by the legal system.

And if they were all the same, they wouldn't each have to be scanned.

I would agree with you only if it was 6 cases of 10 cans each, so only 6 swipes of the barcode.


It isn't a matter of agreeing with me, I didn't say she was right, I said she might have been right, according to the law.

I think it depends on the pricing, whether it would be considered a lot. If she had to buy 10 to get that price, then I would think it would be a lot.

I don't think there is any law regarding the express lane at the supermarket. ;) So I don't think they have to use the "legal" definition of what an item is.
 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91
Originally posted by: ElFenix
i think if you get in line with the correct number of items, items picked up while in line (candy) should not count against the total

Around here some supermarkets have signs that say "About 12 Items or Fewer" so there's a little bit of a buffer.
 

shopbruin

Diamond Member
Jul 12, 2000
5,817
0
0
Originally posted by: mugs
I wish Costco would put in an express lane, but I know that doesn't make any sense for them. :D Maybe I need to get a bigger freezer.

an express lane would be freaking awesome at costco. sometimes i'm just going in and i walk out with a box of granola bars and two cases of water. i don't want to wait behind someone with 20 cases of soda, 10 packs of meat, and 3 boxes of lettuce!
 

theknight571

Platinum Member
Mar 23, 2001
2,896
2
81
If it was 60 cans of the same item, and the cashier claims that each item needs to be scaned then she needs better training. <QTY 60... scan> 3 keystrokes and a swipe.

I've gone through express lanes with far more "items" than the limit says, but much of them were multiples of the same thing.

Although once I had a cashier rudely tell me that I had to many items (actually I had accidently gotten in the express lane and didn't realize it) so, since she was rude about it, I put 12 items on the belt, then a seperator, then the rest of my items. I told her they were two seperate orders. LOL. Had she been nice about it I would have apologized and moved lanes.... however I can't stand rudeness. :)

Fortunately the guy behind me in line thought it was funny and didn't give me a hard time. As I recall I was only over by 4-5 items anyway.
 

Tom

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
13,293
1
76
btw, what constitutes being in line anyway ?

If I put my stuff on the conveyor belt, and go grab a Snickers, have I lost my space ?

How far can I go ?

 

Kelvrick

Lifer
Feb 14, 2001
18,422
5
81
Originally posted by: theknight571
If it was 60 cans of the same item, and the cashier claims that each item needs to be scaned then she needs better training. <QTY 60... scan> 3 keystrokes and a swipe.

I've gone through express lanes with far more "items" than the limit says, but much of them were multiples of the same thing.

Although once I had a cashier rudely tell me that I had to many items (actually I had accidently gotten in the express lane and didn't realize it) so, since she was rude about it, I put 12 items on the belt, then a seperator, then the rest of my items. I told her they were two seperate orders. LOL. Had she been nice about it I would have apologized and moved lanes.... however I can't stand rudeness. :)

Fortunately the guy behind me in line thought it was funny and didn't give me a hard time. As I recall I was only over by 4-5 items anyway.

If I owned a store, I wouldn't trust the customer on the number of items if its just in a pile.

Originally posted by: TomIt isn't a matter of agreeing with me, I didn't say she was right, I said she might have been right, according to the law.

I think it depends on the pricing, whether it would be considered a lot. If she had to buy 10 to get that price, then I would think it would be a lot.

Yea, and I was agreeing that she would have been legal IF they had been in their cases and not individuals.
 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91
Originally posted by: freesia39
Originally posted by: mugs
I wish Costco would put in an express lane, but I know that doesn't make any sense for them. :D Maybe I need to get a bigger freezer.

an express lane would be freaking awesome at costco. sometimes i'm just going in and i walk out with a box of granola bars and two cases of water. i don't want to wait behind someone with 20 cases of soda, 10 packs of meat, and 3 boxes of lettuce!

The nice thing about Costco is that they have very low turnover, so I've been able to pick out which cashiers are the fastest.

Originally posted by: Tom
btw, what constitutes being in line anyway ?

If I put my stuff on the conveyor belt, and go grab a Snickers, have I lost my space ?

How far can I go ?

That's just rude. I saw a person load up the conveyor belt with a line behind her, and then she left and didn't come back before it was her turn! So the cashier had a conveyor full of stuff with nowhere to put it and a line full of pissed off customers.

You know it's funny though, people will take their time wandering through the aisles and spend an hour in the store shopping, but once they're ready to go they have to be out the door in 30 seconds or they're pissed!