I suck, cpu fan direction advice please

slayer202

Lifer
Nov 27, 2005
13,679
119
106
I've been waiting to install this thing, and of course in the meantime I haven't figured out the fan. Antec sonata 2 case, rear exhaust fan. Corsair a50 cooler. Do I install the fan pulling air from the heatsink towards the rear fan? They'll be pretty close to each other. Or should I push through from the other side of the heatsink?
 

Terzo

Platinum Member
Dec 13, 2005
2,589
27
91
My guess is that you'll want to heatsink fan to blow air through the heatsink, so you'd have...

Rear Fan...Heatsink... Heatsink Fan.

At least, that's how I have mine done.

Take this with a grain of salt though, I'm not exactly a guru when it comes to component cooling.
 

slayer202

Lifer
Nov 27, 2005
13,679
119
106
Well shit, I just realized that the fan won't fit on that side, the ram is in the way. I hope I can assume the two fans close to each other will be alright?
 

Terzo

Platinum Member
Dec 13, 2005
2,589
27
91
That probably depends on your processor, heatsink, and the fans in your case.

My guess is that running the heatsink fan in pull will be more akin to having two exhausts and a passive heatsink. From what I understand, the heatsink fin density affects how well this works. Denser fin spacing will allow better transfer of heat from the cpu to the heatsink, but will also make it more difficult for air to flow through the heatsink.

So then the question becomes will your case generate enough airflow to "passively" cool the processor? For reference, SPCR was able to passively cool a pentium in their mini p180.

It has very good cooling performance, better than the P182, given that its vent area is about double, and its stock fans probably capable of twice the airflow. Remember that the test system's Intel Pentium D950 — rated at 130W TDP, which is as hot as the hottest of today's quad-cores — was fitted with a underperforming, fanless Ninja heatsink... and in the Mini P180, it still provided excellent cooling.
However, the mini p180 has a large 200mm top fan and 120 rear fan, so it can generate a lot of air flow. Additionally, the Ninja Mini has relatively large spacing between fins, which makes it easier for air to flow. Still, that's and old sff heatsink so I bet many newer designs should be able to keep up. Taking into that I doubt your processor has a larger TDP than the tested pentium...

If your case has multiple exhaust fans (preferably one on the top), I think you'll be fine using the heatsink fan in pull. Probably would be better if you can find a way to fit it properly (are you using all ram slots?) though.

Give it a shot and keep an eye on the temps. If they get too high, then I was wrong.
 

slayer202

Lifer
Nov 27, 2005
13,679
119
106
well I've got it installed, I'm losing my mind mixing up pull, push, whatever the hell. I've got the fan a couple inches from the rear fan, blowing air in the same direction. cpu temps are good, I'll keep an eye on system temps but I assume they are ok as well
 

Kenmitch

Diamond Member
Oct 10, 1999
8,505
2,250
136
The fins looks pretty spaced in the photos on the Corsair site so maybe pull will work out fine for you....Just keep an eye on temps!

Only other option would be to shift the fan up enough to clear the ram. Looks like the fan shrowd locks onto the fins in the photos. Not sure if the bottom of the fan shrowd is incased or not but could be cut if needed. Looking at photos to me it looks like you could maybe raise the fan about 1/2"
 

slayer202

Lifer
Nov 27, 2005
13,679
119
106
The fins looks pretty spaced in the photos on the Corsair site so maybe pull will work out fine for you....Just keep an eye on temps!

Only other option would be to shift the fan up enough to clear the ram. Looks like the fan shrowd locks onto the fins in the photos. Not sure if the bottom of the fan shrowd is incased or not but could be cut if needed. Looking at photos to me it looks like you could maybe raise the fan about 1/2"

hmm, hadn't thought of that. I can take a look tomorrow, thanks for the tip