I love peanut butter, especially if it doesn't bear any resemblance to what actually happens to a peanut when you smash it. Organic peanut butter is clearly something someone scraped out of a cat's litter box. Give me JIF any day.
This must not be so. You have deprived yourself of the natural brands that wish to actually make something worth our time.
If you can find it (I imagine they have limited distribution capability - ordering online is always an option), I recommend you try this:
http://www.krema.com/Creamy-Peanut-Butter-16-oz-Jar/productinfo/PBCRE1/
One ingredient: roasted peanuts
It is quite smooth and creamy, but it has a little more of that tongue sticks to the roof of your mouth quality. Like the other natural products, it does tend to separate a bit as well. A good first stir sets it up to stay well for awhile, so if you use it fast no refrigeration is needed. It is not needed, technically, one bit - and it does stay well in the fridge, though it loses its easy to spread nature.
I haven't had it in a long while, as I am always a fan of Jif and it is more agreeable to my wallet to buy that at Costco. That, and when others are using it, it helps for them to agree with the peanut butter choice.