I have 2 power supplies what one to keep? Corsair AX1200i and EVGA 1300 g2.. And Why

FiLeZz

Diamond Member
Jun 16, 2000
4,778
47
91
Corsair Ax1200i. Or 1300 g2 evga

I had to rma my ax1200 this was my second rma. Corsair sent back an ax1200i

Do I just stay with the evga 1300gs2 or sell the gs 2 and run the ax1200i

I feel like I will just kill the axi as well.

Running 3930k oc'd and 3x 780gtx oc'd
All on a massive water loop.
 
Last edited:

lehtv

Elite Member
Dec 8, 2010
11,897
74
91
GS2? Do you mean 1300 G2?

Why not keep both? I'd probably just use the AXi and keep the EVGA for backup in case of running into problems with the AXi.
 
Last edited:

FiLeZz

Diamond Member
Jun 16, 2000
4,778
47
91
Yea G2 is what I ment. I have edited the op. Well I wanted to keep what ever power supply that could handle the load. The AX1200 has shown it can not 2 times. Not sure that the ax1200i can do any better. When you RMA this much it gets old. What is your reasoning for using the ax1200i over the evga 1300 g2?
 
Last edited:

lehtv

Elite Member
Dec 8, 2010
11,897
74
91
Well, it wasn't obvious from your OP that the reason you RMA'd the AX1200 was because it couldn't handle the load. Could've been coil whine or some other unrelated reason, for all I know.

If you'd rather use the 1300W unit to be safe(r) then I wonder why you ask for advice in this matter in the first place? The G2 1300W does actually have more power under the hood (108A vs 100A on the +12V), if that's what you're wondering. It's a great unit.

My reasoning for using the AX1200i was higher efficiency (platinum vs gold). I figured 1200W should be enough to handle your setup.
 

FiLeZz

Diamond Member
Jun 16, 2000
4,778
47
91
What is funny is the AX1200 ran ok for about 4-6 months both times. Then just one day it could no longer handle the load. The power supply still worked but under loads it would just reboot the PC..

Hardocp review on the ax1200i was not so grand.
They only gave it a PASS mark. quote below.

" Moving on to the efficiency, we see that this unit was 88.80% to 92.12% at 120v input and 87.93% to 91.16% at 100v input which is excellent. If we then look to the 80 Plus results, we see that the unit was not quite as excellent as it was 87.27%-92.74%-90.40% efficient using 80 Plus’s loads and conditions. This makes the unit a huge miss on the low end, and means that users are not going to likely see 80 Plus Platinum levels of efficiency, as the power range that the AX1200i missed is that which most users will see this power supply operating at the majority of the time. For an otherwise very promising start, this was a big misstep"
 

lehtv

Elite Member
Dec 8, 2010
11,897
74
91
FiLeZz said:
Hardocp review on the ax1200i was not so grand.
Is that the only "bad" thing they had to say about it? JonnyGuru gave it 10/10 in performance, including efficiency. KitGuru who test at 230V found the unit peaked at 93.67% at 50% load. It's not perhaps as much more efficient than the G2 1300 as you'd expect, but it is still a little more efficient.

you know I would keep the evga 1300 and see if it holds up. you may sell the cosair and buy an silvers ton 1500 with that sale money.


http://www.amazon.com/Silverstone-Te...ords=evga+1500

Or a LEPA 1600W which is more efficient and costs the same. The user reviews are a bit iffy but it's also a very small sample of reviews, and JonnyGuru gave it excellent grades.

If money is no issue... dual Antec HCP-850 Platinum linked together. Ridiculously expensive ($450) but at least you'd have 1900W of top notch quality to work with... :D
 
Last edited:

FiLeZz

Diamond Member
Jun 16, 2000
4,778
47
91
Is that the only "bad" thing they had to say about it? JonnyGuru gave it 10/10 in performance, including efficiency. KitGuru who test at 230V found the unit peaked at 93.67% at 50% load. It's not perhaps as much more efficient than the G2 1300 as you'd expect, but it is still a little more efficient.



Or a LEPA 1600W which is more efficient and costs the same. The user reviews are a bit iffy but it's also a very small sample of reviews, and JonnyGuru gave it excellent grades


No they had some other negatives about the power supply along with the good.

Review link.
http://www.hardocp.com/article/2012/10/15/corsair_ax1200i_power_supply_review/9#.U2O2kI0U-yI


The Bottom Line




Corsair has refreshed a lot of its product lines in the last year or so and "refresh" is probably the right term as we have yet to see any of these products truly knock our socks off. Today we looked at Corsair’s newest refresh, the AX1200i and that "refresh" trend has largely continued. Overall, the AX1200i is a very competent performer, with one flash of brilliance. Indeed, the unit displayed very good voltage regulation, excellent efficiency, and the best DC Output quality we have seen to date which is quite the achievement. Where things start going a bit less well is when we look at the Transient Load Test results and the noise output which both trail the previous AX1200; the voltage regulation was also very similar so we could probably include that here as well.



We had some further issues with the AX1200i unit as there were some sloppy fixes in the build quality and the 80 Plus efficiency numbers were not quite up to snuff. With all of this in mind, this unit is certainly in the realm of very good but so are a slew of other units these days and pricing is key. Currently, the AX1200i is retailing at $349.99 compared to things like the Corsair AX1200 at $266.98 with Free Prime Shipping, XFX ProSeries 1250W at $234.99 after $20 MIR, Antec HCP-1200 at $199.99 after $30 MIR, Enermax Platimax 1200W at $309.99; you get the picture. While the AX1200i can compete with most of these units, it does so at a huge price penalty. The AX1200i is a bit hampered again by the fact that it just is not a huge leap forward over the AX1200, except in the DC output quality. In the end the AX1200i just does not dominate it lesser priced competitors. This makes the AX1200i PSU an extremely hard sell to make unless you are buying solely for the ripple/noise values.



To put the pricing on this unit a bit more into perspective, you can buy the Lepa G1600 (reviewed here) for $294.99 after $20 MIR and literally be done buying power supplies for years based on capacity needs in one shot, which is what we would do rather than even think of buying the Corsair AX1200i.



Corsair seems to be coasting rather than innovating when it comes to truly building a better overall power supply. As for the Beta Link software, we were unimpressed with it and it did not seem to bring value to this product which should "work right" without it. As past software solutions have shown for Corsair over its entire product line, software is certainly not Corsair's strong suit, in fact you could likely argue that software is Corsair's Achilles' heel, so seemingly trying to hang its $350 PSU hat on gimmicky software is simply a bad move.