i finally finished Grimrock 2

DigDog

Lifer
Jun 3, 2011
14,674
3,020
136
1 month, 47 savegames, and 18 hours of gameplay.

impressive on the visual level, but i got to say, same problems for me as grimrock 1: the puzzles just lock you out of the game.

too many times i have had to resort to youtube to find out just how some insane puzzle gets solved. the story puzzles are well made, it's easy enough to find the solution with the hints you are given, but simple puzzles such as the spider in the teleporter rely on guessing the shape of the map or some other element one cannot see; and not only do they take tons of trial and error, but sometimes they punish you with a drop down a level, broken legs or a reload.

and none (or barely any) of the puzzles are optional. combat, it seems, it a afterthought addition. the slow advancement would not be a problem in itself if not for the fact that it can lock you out of fundamental abilities for a long while.

finally, and its weird, i think the last portions of the game were far easier than the middle part. they maybe ran out of ideas, or realized how hard they were making it. a few riddles are just insane; "turn and look where the statue look" is easy enough, but omit "but wait for about 20 seconds" and you'll see how 99% of gamers will never, ever solve this puzzle.

all in all, i had fun playing it, but i consider reading spoilers an integral part of the game - do what puzzles you can on your own, and google the rest.
 
Last edited:

Omar F1

Senior member
Sep 29, 2009
491
8
76
Thanks for your game summary.
I was thinking about to play both the 1st and the 2nd one, do you recommend to start with the 1st? Are they story related?
 

Blanky

Platinum Member
Oct 18, 2014
2,457
12
46
Agree with all you said. It took me about 20 hours and by the end I wasn't even reign the puzzles; immediately to youtube. Some of them were so stupid that if my life literally relied upon solving them with an infinite amount of time I don't know what I could have.

The combat was annoying at times. I hated that even with a strong party if I got cornered I could get trashed quickly by lowish level guys. Also the ability to take on even the strongest foes (not including the alternate ending guy who I gave up on because f him) by dancing around in four squares is an inherent weakness in this tile based game.

There is no link between g1 and 2 to my knowledge.
 

DigDog

Lifer
Jun 3, 2011
14,674
3,020
136
i would recommend to only play grimrock 2 and pass on G1. The second game is better in everything; also, the real strength of these two games is that there are a TON of free "modules" that you can simply download for free from their forums, so you will never run out of game to play.