Power Consumtion of Modern Computers
1. You have to look at how efficient your power supply for conversion from AC to DC current.
2. Motherboard consumption & efficiency, how much heat loss + chipsets consumption, integrated components.
3. Graphic, sound, and sound cards.
4. HDD, CDROM & Floppy drives.
5. Monitor
6. Speakers, mouse & keyboard.
Realistically with regular minimal use for email, web serfing, and the occasionall music listening is very likely below $5.00 per month, mild use with some gaming would be somewhere around $7-8:00 per month, heavy use of about 8 hours of gaming per day would cost roughtly $10-12:00 per month (base on 50W speakers system & 100W CTR monitor). Shutting off you computer, monitor & speakers when not in use would save you roughtly $3:00 per month.
I don't think that you would save much money shutting off your computer when not in use, but it is a good habit to get into, because it will lead to a more conservative life style, such as use less hot/cold water, turn off your car when park, lights off when not in use, don't use the dryer as often during summer months.