I am not Chinese and love american Chinese food, and it is OVERPRICED CRAP!
The one around here is where all these pseudowealthy people go to show off, the type that brag about going to "Panera's (which is also crappy overpriced stuff)" for lunch, when all they could afford to order was a side salad.
It is a place where wannabe snobs go, without the millions to back up the super snop attitude, driving their baby Mercedes.
Not to mention I hate to be able to walk in a place and see everyone eating, no table privacy at all.
As you can see I loathe this place and the type of people that go there.
EDIT: After reading the whole thread, I have some more to add. Yes, we already had this discussion on ATOT, and we concluded that it sucks, but that was before it was trendy.
Moving on to trendy, I completely agree, it is the starbucks of chinese food, people flock there as if they were sheep, to follow to sheep mentality.
And YES $10-$12 portions that are on the small side is expensive, as I can go to about 10 other places around here (without even going to the awesome China Town in philly) that offer much better food and atmosphere for a much better price and bigger servings.