How is it that one can't debate with the regulars on H&F?

[alkemyst]

http://forums.anandtech.com/showthread.php?t=2062143

I don't get this. If anything Deeko, Jack Ryan and myself were the one's being attacked (myself again personally with a comment like 'old fat guy' which goes well with the other time someone called me a 'jheri curled mongoloid' or something) and we get either the infraction or the thread is locked and a warning.

You ask for someone's experience and that is off limits, you cite your own experience and that's just ancedotal...yet you have a bunch of noobs to the fitness world just linking to the same few places as an answer to everything and if you don't agree a mod get involved.

sort of sad really how that subforum has really become the private forums for about 3 dudes.

 

[olds]

Are you kidding? I only read your first two replies and they add NOTHING to the topic. You were trolling.

 

[alkemyst]

Not trolling at all. I don't agree with 'core exercises' being just doing whatever rippetoe has in his book.

While squats and deadlfts do that, they aren't target exercises.

I still don't get how I can get personally attacked and then I end up with the infraction.

If I called someone basically a great person or the like I am sure I'd be on vacation a long time. Seems to fly fine against me.

 

[olds]

IMHO, if you had started out explaining why you felt as you just explained, you'd have been fine. Instead, you started out trolling. How do you not see this?

 

[alkemyst]

http://forums.anandtech.com/showpost.php?p=29609600&postcount=8

My first reply. Then it became rippetoe or nothing in it.

So then I mentioned lets add in x-fit.

that's all the kids know...rippletoe and cross-fit.

 

[Red Dawn]

http://forums.anandtech.com/showthread.php?t=2062143

I don't get this. If anything Deeko, Jack Ryan and myself were the one's being attacked (myself again personally with a comment like 'old fat guy' which goes well with the other time someone called me a 'jheri curled mongoloid' or something) and we get either the infraction or the thread is locked and a warning.

You ask for someone's experience and that is off limits, you cite your own experience and that's just ancedotal...yet you have a bunch of noobs to the fitness world just linking to the same few places as an answer to everything and if you don't agree a mod get involved.

sort of sad really how that subforum has really become the private forums for about 3 dudes.

Yet if asked the vast majority of those who participate in that forum would point you out as a disruptive influence which you have been since you decided to grace H&F with your presence. Since you've started to participate there the bickering has increased ten fold. I won't have it and if you continue you will not be allowed to post there.