Seems like most people use the French/Italian 'ay'... but sorbet is originally Turkish. I've got weird looks all my life for saying 'it', people like to correct you when they think they're right 
I think the general consensus on it is that either is correct, but in my opinion it's much more fun to say 'it'. Also, 'ay' makes it sound too sweet.
I think the general consensus on it is that either is correct, but in my opinion it's much more fun to say 'it'. Also, 'ay' makes it sound too sweet.