I'll be honest and reveal how I voted.
As to intelligence: I am a successful (though unhappy) IP lawyer, and graduated near the top of my class. I was also the editor of a law journal. Thus, I consider myself of above-average intelligence relative to the average poster on this forum.
As to athleticism: in highschool I was scouted by numerous pro baseball teams and division 1 colleges as a pitcher. I was first team all state for 3 years before I snapped the post medial epicondle tendon in my right arm in the middle of a pitch. But seeing as how I could throw a ball 93 MPH as a sophomore in highschool, I think it is safe to say that I was and still am more athletic than most on this forum.
As to attractiveness: I'll be honest. I am an ugly bastard. I've got a huge sqashed nose (mainly because I broke it severely by taking a line drive to the face), bad teeth (thanks to bad genes and a bout with stupidity as a teen), and generally unsymmetrical features. I am also presently in the worst shape of my life, as my job (which pretty much dominates my life) prevents me from getting much exercise.