How are issues with the Master Browser and Domain List not more common?

smitbret

Diamond Member
Jul 27, 2006
3,382
17
81
My network has been driving me nuts since I decided to go all in and set up my house with a true gigabit network a year or so ago. I was cursed with stretches where it would work smoothly and then be driven completely insane by PCs dropping off the network or slow browsing between PCs and the internet grinding to a halt. I would think I had it fixed, only to discover a couple of weeks later that the same issues would pop up. I've thrown 4 routers, a wireless bridge, 3 switches, 2 modems and a few hundred feet of Cat 5e and Cat6 cabling at the situation. I've even messed with routers and alternate firmware. Moved routers and switches and modems around. I even called the cable internet company and blamed it on their equipment assigning DHCP addresses to my equipment even though I knew it probably wasn't true......... it nearly drove me to making a Cat5e noose and kicking the office chair out from beneath my feet.

So, I finally got my network issues resolved. It has been rock solid and running smoothly for a couple of weeks. Networked PCs finally pop up within seconds (instead of minutes, if at all) in Explorer and I can shuffle between shared folders on different PCs with ease. My media streaming devices don't lose the Media Libraries anymore and I don't get blocked from accessing shared folders that I knew I had set for access. I am finally realizing my dream from 18 months ago.

The solution, setting the registry on my WHS 2011 Server as the default Master Browser and making it the keeper of the Domain List.

Looking back, most of the problems occurred when I set up my WDTV Live Hub and I never figured it out till hooking up my Rapberry Pi. When I finally started digging into the issues I temporarily resolved it by disabling Samba on the Pi. Then it kept popping back up intermittently. After lots of audits, I noted that the WDTV Live Hub kept setting itself as the Master Browser when it was on and connected. For some reason, these low powered Linux devices always win the Election when they join the network and they just do a poor job.

I guess this post is just more of an FYI, but looking back, I wish that there was more content out there on this. I'm surprised that with the number of devices on networks that people aren't running into this issue more frequently. Seems like a quick check that should be in the most basic network troubleshooting.
 

azazel1024

Senior member
Jan 6, 2014
901
2
76
A lot of people don't have "alternative" devices like that.

From my sole experience, I haven't had anything grab master browser control that shouldn't and then mess things up. My always on server retains control 95% of the time, occasionally my desktop wrestles control away.

I have a general issue where my windows tablet doesn't want to see other machines on my network, but it can still navigate to them by punching in the IP address or qualified name and other things don't always want to see my tablet. Odds are good I have a setting on in network discovery on one or more devices. So I guess I do have some limited issues where things won't always see other things, but I don't have any issues still accessing what I want.

My current device list is a Win8 SMB/CIFS file/iTunes/Calibre server, Win 8.1 desktop, Win 8.1 tablet, 2 iPhones (4s and 5), iPad 2, 2 Android tablets, an Apple TV gen 3, Seagate Free Agent Theater+, xbone, MoCA bridge, router, access point and a pair of 16 port semi-managed switches (and a poop ton of LAN drops) composing my network.
 
Last edited:

Zxian

Senior member
May 26, 2011
579
0
0
Windows networking is built upon the assumption that you have a server. The Master Browser functionality was a workaround to allow clients to communicate directly with each other without having a server active.

If you're actually running under a domain, these kinds of problems should never happen (note: should :p).