Originally posted by: Gibson486
my gf wants a new notebook harddrive. She has two requirements:
Over 120GB
Must be very quiet.
Does this fit the bill?
Yes, this is the latest and greatest LAPTOP drive - 4th generation Hitachi Travelstar - big, fast, quiet, low power consumption, yada, yada, yada...
I was tossed up between this and a Western Digital Scorpio Black, which is WD's latest and greatest.
Hit won the toss! I was just waiting for a sale...
😀
Drive noise is relative to which lappy you're running. I've noticed that when someone complains about noisy HD in reviews - almost 100% of the time it's an Apple user! How about you - ever notice that yourself?
Sound has everything to do with the 'sound qualities' of the case, and hardly anything to do with the drive itself, IMHO.
Put another way, I think certain thin, lightweight, plasticy (if that's a word) lappys tend to amplify HD noise - other 'heavier' ones don't!
Talking about Docking Stations (ahem)... You can put the same 'noisy' HD into a dock/external enclosure and it will be perfectly quiet! So, it ALL depends on YOUR machine!
Anyway, to wrap this up...
Hitachi 7K320 vs WD Scorpio Black 320G 7K - which to choose?
Hit & WD are both big, fast, quiet, and relatively cheap - so it becomes a personal matter, and...
Personally, I'll always choose a Western Digital drive when it absolutely, positively, has to fail - but prefer Toshy & Hit drives when they absolutely, positively, have to succeed - like in a airport concourse, conference hall, or hotel room, 3000 miles away from home - but that's just me!
Your choice! How much do you like your GF???
😉