Hot Deals moderators not following own rules?

MarkM

Senior member
Oct 16, 2001
394
0
0
An update (?) of the Hot Deals forum rules were just posted link

In this post was written:


<< No thread crapping. If the subject matter of deal does not interest you, do not post negative comments about it, or about other members, in the thread.No thread crapping.

Possibly the worst examples we have had of this have been in posts for free religious items, such as bibles, etc. If you want to discuss religion, or any other such non-computer topic, do it in our Off Topic forum. The discussions in that forum cover a wide range of topics, but needless flaming and rude, mean-spirited posts are not welcome there, either.
>>


recently the mods have taken to locking (or even all out deleting!) any hot deals with a religous angle, including one I think of the very example above, a free bible. Now, I am just confused, or doesn't the fact that the forums rules themselves use an example of a free bible hot deal post to talk about discourteous REPLIES to hot deal posts, doesn't it implicitly define a free bible post as a VALID got deal?

I personally don't really care about these religious hot deals, I don't post them nor do I think I am likely to pursue them. But call me a ACLU sympathizer, I don't like to see what I consider as censorship -- or at the VERY LEAST, if there is going to be censorship, I would like it to at least be in the open, and that censorship to be CONSISTENT with the stated policies of the censors!
 

AzAbyss

Senior member
May 29, 2001
220
0
0
It's not the deal they object to, it's all the people arguing about their beliefs in that same thread. That's why Off Topic exists. They aren't trying to stifle anyones beliefs, they just want them argued in Off Topic because thats where they belong.

-Az

[EDIT] The reason they started locking those threads was to get people to realize that Hot Deals is not an appropriate forum to debate ones personal beliefs. They have said that after a "cooling down period" they will let religious items be posted freely again.
 

Ryan

Lifer
Oct 31, 2000
27,519
2
81
I would rather have them lock it, then to have a bunch of idiots insult someone's religion. If you don't worship their god, or don't worship a god at all, that's fine. But you don't have to put down other's beliefs.