I would disagree. I received Homeworld in trade for some work I had done just over a month ago and loved it. Primarily because it was the first game in a long time that was truly kicking my butt.

And the 3D movement was a nice change too.
I picked up Cataclysm thinking I'd enjoy it as much, but so far, i don't. I wish they had kept the interface the same, what with the hiding toolbar and all. The space maps are altered just enough so they don't agree with me too. The story line is great, their concept for new ships and their uses are fantastic, it's just that interface that I can't get past.
Why'd they have to mess with a good thing?