Kansas City, MO
2 Cars, two drivers (my wife and myself), both over 25
Each car runs about $60/month for insurance, probably $125 total.
1 accident, 5 months ago, hit and run (they hit us, not the other way around
), didn't increase the rate at all.
I think we use American Family.
<edit>
These figures are for comprehensive coverage. My car has a $1000 deductible, my wife's has a $250 deductible.
</edit>