Damn, thats quite a bit. I got mine yesterday, its $819 for 6-months if I pay it off at once, about $900 if I dont. How old are you? I would recommend getting insurance through AAA, thats what I did. My rate would have been lower, but I had an accident end of last year that caused it to increase.
when i first got my car when i was 18, i was paying $200/mo through geico. now I pay $70 a month for a 92 jeep cherokee through USAA, and I'm 22. do you have family in the military? USAA has good prices from what I've seen.
Also, raise your deductibles if they are low. Insurance is to protect you against what you can't handle on your own, so it's unwise to pay a high insurance premium to have a $100 deductible when you could save money with a $500 deductible. Ask your agent what the difference would be if you raised it.
Kansas City, MO
2 Cars, two drivers (my wife and myself), both over 25
Each car runs about $60/month for insurance, probably $125 total.
1 accident, 5 months ago, hit and run (they hit us, not the other way around ), didn't increase the rate at all.
I think we use American Family.
These figures are for comprehensive coverage. My car has a $1000 deductible, my wife's has a $250 deductible.