In elementary and junior high I was almost always picked first or second... then in high school I was in the middle of the pack. But it usually depends on the sport.
I got picked last for I think the first time ever last week playing football. There were only 6 of us, and we are all very athletic, but they underestimated me I guess. But lets just say that 3 touchdown catches and an interception later, they decided I was better than they had thought.