Help with PC Joystick choice

GullyFoyle

Diamond Member
Dec 13, 2000
4,362
11
81
I have a Thrustmaster Top Gun Fox 2 Pro Joystick I have been using for many years. I use it for Battlefield games primarily. Recently I noticed that the twist rudder only works marginally clockwise, counter-clockwise is fine. This makes it pretty useless for flying choppers.

I have been pretty happy with this stick, so it didn't take long to identify it's successor, the Thrustmaster T Flight Stick-X.

I browsed around a little more, and I see this slightly higher priced alternative, the Thrustmaster T-16000M Flight Stick. It's primary claim to fame is Hall Effect sensors, which are much more precise, and not prone to failures like potentiometers.

I can't decide which to purchase. Here's what I see as the pro's and con's of the more expensive option:

Pros:

  • Hall effect sensors are more precise
  • Hall effect sensors are likely to remain longer
  • Slightly better reviews overall

Cons:

  • More expensive
  • Ambidexterous design compromises ergonomics (I'm a rightie)
  • Some Button locations harder to use without looking
Anyone care to weigh in on how they would decide?

Or, should I take my current stick apart and try to fix the failing rudder with some tuner cleaner?

TIA!
 

shortylickens

No Lifer
Jul 15, 2003
80,287
17,081
136
I gotta be completely honest here: None of the Battlefield games qualify as simulators. If thats all you are doing, just go with whatever is cheapest.

I will say easy to find buttons are more important in a fast action game.