Help Choosing a Widescreen LCD

imported_Redwood

Junior Member
Mar 28, 2007
8
0
0
I need help choosing a widescreen LCD monitor. Here's what I'm looking at - while I understand that there's no such thing as a perfect monitor, I need the closest thing to it. I do a lot of professional image and video editing, in addition to running office apps and games. So, a tentative list of requirements (although they're all what you'd expect from someone looking for as perfect a monitor as possible):


Wide color gamut
Accurate colors (however, it's acceptable for the monitor to require calibration in order to achieve this)
Brightness homogeneity
Low response time
Wide viewing angle with minimal distortion and drop in brightness
High contrast and brightness
Multiple switchable inputs (at minimum, it needs to be able to handle 2 PCs)
Widescreen
1920 x 1200


I'd like as high a resolution as I can get (maximizing size while minimizing pixel pitch), and from the research I've done, my understanding is that a 24" 1920 x 1200 is going to be as large as is practical. I'm willing to go with a slightly smaller display (i.e. 22-23") as long as I don't drop below 1920 x 1200, since I'm currently running 1600 x 1200 on a CRT.

Unfortunately, my understanding also is that it's not a good idea to look at anything with a higher resolution than 1920 x 1200, due to a host of other limitations coming into play (No OSD, limited input options, no native control of image scaling, no HDCP, etc...), so I guess I'm stuck at 1900 x 1200.

Price is not a serious concern, but visual inconsistencies and other glitches are. To give you an idea, I can look at a mirror or through a piece of glass and point out every spot that isn't optically perfect, so uneven brightness, flicker, or other such visual issues are particularly problematical for me.



In looking for monitors that fit the bill, the Samsung 244T came up as a possible contender, but it's also a bit dated at this point, and I have to wonder if there's anything better on the market.

I'm not even sure what panel type would be considered the best at the moment, since most guides I've run across are a bit dated and don't take into account the most recent developments. Should I be looking for AS-IPS, A-TW-IPS, A-MVA, or something else?


In any case, any help will be appreciated! TIA! :)
 

kmmatney

Diamond Member
Jun 19, 2000
4,363
1
81
Pretty much all 1920 x 1200 24" LCDs are very good quality, so it doesn[t matter which one you get. The Dell 2407 and the Gateway 24" LCD are both good. BenQ also makes a good 24" LCD. I'm not a big fan of the Samsung PVA panel (I use one at work) but even that is a good monitor. In other words, any 24" 1920 x 1200 LCD will be very high quality LCD (and won't be cheap).
 

imported_Redwood

Junior Member
Mar 28, 2007
8
0
0
Originally posted by: kmmatney

Pretty much all 1920 x 1200 24" LCDs are very good quality, so it doesn[t matter which one you get. The Dell 2407 and the Gateway 24" LCD are both good. BenQ also makes a good 24" LCD. I'm not a big fan of the Samsung PVA panel (I use one at work) but even that is a good monitor. In other words, any 24" 1920 x 1200 LCD will be very high quality LCD (and won't be cheap).


I'm afraid that I have to disagree with that. There are always differences - some positive and some negative - between various models. And it's not always insignificant.

For example, BenQ's FP241WZ has gotten poor reviews due to the BFI-that's-not-really-BFI technology. Aside from the bait and switch they're pulling, it suffers from both a significant loss of brightness as well as uneven brightness and twinkling. Using this monitor for Photoshop work is completely unacceptable, as you can see the screening on solid color backgrounds, not to mention black spots and twinkling.


I would therefore have to rule this monitor out solidly. And thus, I can't take for granted that all the others would be just fine either. :)
 

alaricljs

Golden Member
May 11, 2005
1,221
1
76
If that's what you're looking for and it's going to be used 'professionally' then the NEC MultiSync LCD2490WUXi is closest to what you're looking for from what I've read.

Understand that this is a great monitor at 3x the price of a Dell 2407FPW. It is distinctly aimed at the professional market.


 

craftech

Senior member
Nov 26, 2000
779
4
81
I just went through the same thing as you are going through for the past month. I also do video editing for a living. In the end I decided that LCD technology isn't ready for prime time when it comes to editing video. I decided to keep my Sony Trinitron 21" CRT.
But I also output to a professional video editing monitor as well:

http://www.ggvideo.com/jvc_tmh150cgu.php

John