Heatsink but no fan => video cards

Magic Carpet

Diamond Member
Oct 2, 2011
3,477
234
106
Would it not be nice if there was a range of video cards coming out just with the heatsinks, minus the fans.

The heatsink would have standard mountings for 90 or 120 fans.

Would make my life so much easier. Can't deal with stock fans anymore. Even the so-called quiet fans are loud to my standard.
 
Last edited:

Puppies04

Diamond Member
Apr 25, 2011
5,909
17
76
If you are going to replace fans then you need to get to exactly the same point of disassembly as you would start if you got a GPU with no fans. So you aren't saving much time. Are you complaining about the $3 extra you pay for the included fans or something else because I don't understand what exactly you are moaning about???
 

Magic Carpet

Diamond Member
Oct 2, 2011
3,477
234
106
If you are going to replace fans then you need to get to exactly the same point of disassembly as you would start if you got a GPU with no fans. So you aren't saving much time. Are you complaining about the $3 extra you pay for the included fans or something else because I don't understand what exactly you are moaning about???
Not every card offers an easy fan swap, the cooling designs can vary significantly between vendors. People that silence computers (video incl.) know exactly what I am talking about.

Where did my humble feature-suggestion look like moaning to you? Your loss is somebody's gain.

Apparently, this is the wrong forum for these sorts of ideas. My apologies.
 
Last edited:

digitalbuda

Member
Jul 10, 2010
116
0
76
I took the cover off my 9800GTX+ and strapped an 80mm fan directly to the heatsink. Now my temps never go above 65C during heavy gaming. When I turn the fan up to 100% I get 45C max.
 

MrTeal

Diamond Member
Dec 7, 2003
3,919
2,708
136
My dream card would be something like the Powercolor SCS3, but with a 7970 instead of the 6850 and mounting clips/holes so I could toss a 120mm S-Flex on there. The aftermarket coolers are nice, but they do make some compromises in order to make them universal.
 

Magic Carpet

Diamond Member
Oct 2, 2011
3,477
234
106
I took the cover off my 9800GTX+ and strapped an 80mm fan directly to the heatsink. Now my temps never go above 65C during heavy gaming. When I turn the fan up to 100% I get 45C max.
That's one of the practical ways to do it. What kind of fan, did you use? 90mm wouldn't fit? Did you solder it to the board or plugged it directly in to your mobo?

My dream card would be something like the Powercolor SCS3, but with a 7970 instead of the 6850 and mounting clips/holes so I could toss a 120mm S-Flex on there. The aftermarket coolers are nice, but they do make some compromises in order to make them universal.
That 6850 SCS3 isn't my dream card. It's just too bulky. I'd rather have a compact size with a drop-in 90/120 fan design. That way, it would be easy to replace from a great selection of fans currently available on the market and have good temps at the same time. Running a card at 90c+, isn't just right. You could probably attach a fan to the SCS3 and solve the temp issue though. If you want to pay the price premium for it, in the first place.

the arctic cooling stuff is good and quite. Thermalright makes a nice solution as well.
Correct. Problem is the additional cost and man-hours. Wouldn't have been as much of a problem, had the cards been selling HSF-less [like OEM CPUs].

From a design point of view, it would be far better / cheaper, if vendors actually give more choice to the consumer in the cooling department. I'd rather pay $30 more and get a Noctua fan.. actually mounted right, on a card than have it pre-overclocked and dealing with the noise instead. Two quiet 90/120x fans would provide necessary performance and acoustic level for the majority of consumers. Sure, you could custom-mod it yourself but that's just PITA and I'd pay a bit more to have some options and not being restricted to a particular hard to find, let alone expensive model.

IMO, this would be a great marketing feature. Right at this moment, we have 2 extremes... hot & bulky and cool & loud. Nothing in the middle.
 
Last edited:

digitalbuda

Member
Jul 10, 2010
116
0
76
That's one of the practical ways to do it. What kind of fan, did you use? 90mm wouldn't fit? Did you solder it to the board or plugged it directly in to your mobo?

Its a regular 80mm case fan I had laying around with a molex power plug and its held in place by ziptie. Its not pretty but it works
 

Magic Carpet

Diamond Member
Oct 2, 2011
3,477
234
106
Its a regular 80mm case fan I had laying around with a molex power plug and its held in place by ziptie. Its not pretty but it works
I have it in mind. Only problem, you can't control the speed via molex, unless you voltmodded it. At least, you didn't have to pay for the fan :thumbsup:
 

digitalbuda

Member
Jul 10, 2010
116
0
76
Actually the 80mm case fan is normal speed that I can't control. What I meant by turning up the fan 100% is the built-in fan that came with the card, I should've clarified that in the beginning. So 2 fans in total.
 

Magic Carpet

Diamond Member
Oct 2, 2011
3,477
234
106
Actually the 80mm case fan is normal speed that I can't control. What I meant by turning up the fan 100% is the built-in fan that came with the card, I should've clarified that in the beginning. So 2 fans in total.
Ah right. Thanks for clearing that up. I take it, by no means it is a quiet setup?
 

njdevilsfan87

Platinum Member
Apr 19, 2007
2,346
267
126
I think the issue with standard case fans and video card heat sinks the 25mm fan width - it's just too much given the little space when designing a video card heat sink. The metal in the heat sinks themselves take up nearly 2 slots as it is.
 

Magic Carpet

Diamond Member
Oct 2, 2011
3,477
234
106
I think the issue with standard case fans and video card heat sinks the 25mm fan width - it's just too much given the little space when designing a video card heat sink. The metal in the heat sinks themselves take up nearly 2 slots as it is.
Valid point.

A quiet 3-slot video card > noisy 2-slot video card, in my book anyway.
 

Bill Brasky

Diamond Member
May 18, 2006
4,324
1
0
The squirrel cage fan in my 5850 rattles at idle due to hitting the shroud and it's so annoying I've completely stopped using my desktop despite the money I just spent in upgrades. Ever since I put a SSD in my laptop, it's *by far* the most quiet machine I've ever owned. It's such a pleasure to use, I only boot up my desktop once a week or so when I game.