• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

hard drive brands

B

BriGy86

Diamond Member
mine crapped out after about a year (seagate) and i don't know if i am able to send it in on warrenty

i put up the 3 big name ones to go with, let me know if there is a reason to go with anything else

is there a speed issue i should know about between SATA and IDE?

i was told they go at the same speed
 
Well...just make sure, you go Seagate, I don't think anyone can argue Seagate> Western Digital > maxtor I dont kno wmuch about Sata v.s IDE
 
well the drive that crapped out on me was a seagate, and i only had it for a year, thats why i was thinking about the other brands

especially the raptor
 
Originally posted by: BriGy86
so is SATA faster?

it goes at 150 right and IDE only reaches 133?
Click to expand...

SATA 150 isn't any faster in the realworld than IDE 133 is. It's just a marketing gimmick for most SATA drives. If you go for SATA, assume the only benefits you'll receive is a newer interface and a smaller cable.

Originally posted by: mOeeOm

Seagate> Western Digital > maxtor
Click to expand...

:thumbsup:

Originally posted by: BriGy86
well the drive that crapped out on me was a seagate, and i only had it for a year, thats why i was thinking about the other brands

especially the raptor
Click to expand...

IMO, you just got a dud. Happens with all brands, unfortunately.

As far as the Raptor goes, I'd say it's not that great of a buy for most people.

What are you PC specs and what do you use it for?
 
SATA isn't a huge leap forward from IDE, but if you're motherboard has SATA and you're buying a new HDD get a SATA.

Personally, my I have WD's in a few machines, and they all work perfectly well.

Really, WD or Seagate are both good. I think Seagate is a little more expenise, but also a little bit quieter.

RoD
 
Originally posted by: BriGy86
well the drive that crapped out on me was a seagate, and i only had it for a year, thats why i was thinking about the other brands

especially the raptor
Click to expand...


Yes, but happens with any brand, like my old maxtor lasted 4 years...but maxtor seems to have the highest failing rate, so buy with caution.
 
okie dokie, ill wipe the drive then see if i can send it in for warrenty and get a new one back... thats how it work more or less right?
 
Originally posted by: BriGy86
okie dokie, ill wipe the drive then see if i can send it in for warrenty and get a new one back... thats how it work more or less right?
Click to expand...


yup 🙂
 
For my next one, I'm thinking about this hot Maxtor Atlas 15k II! 🙂 $199 shipped. Now where can I get $199... 😕

For ATA drives, I'd probably get Seagate (yay, guaranteed fluid bearings) and focus on getting 8MB cache first. Interface-wise... mmmm... whatever. I could see myself breaking the SATA data connector off of my SATA drive if I were careless, now wouldn't that be fun. PATA connectors are physically almost unbreakable.

If the long cables or the one-drive-per-cable aspect of SATA benefit you, those could be points in SATA's favor (no need to put two hard drives close to eachother so the cable can reach them both). Also, if you use some SATA drives, that leaves you more PATA positions for other drives. Some people need all the drives they can get to store their, uh... 😱 yeah.
 
i hope maxtor goes out of business like connor/quantum. compared to either of these, it's just as crap and should have been dead years ago.
 
Western Digital or Seagate - I doubt you actually notice a difference.

I'd go with whoever is cheaper.
 
No experience with Seagate... I've been using Western Digitals without any issues for a few years now, I love 'em.
Used some Maxtors before the WDs, nothing but problems, I'll never again get any mainstream Maxtor drive.
 
I've been using Seagate for a long time. I like it a lot. I haven't had problems. They're uber quiet too and have a long warranty. And also, go to seagate's site. Do the RMA thing, I thought I didn't have a warranty on a seagate that died. On the box it said it had a 3 year warranty, and it actually had 5 years. So, get that checked out...
 
I have not had a bad experience with maxtor. I have owned about 10 seagate hard drives, 3 maxtors, 2 WD's and a Hitachi, and none of them have given me problems. On average, I find the maxtors to be a little quicker than the other drives. I can personaly recomend the DiamondMax III's and MaxLines (with 16mb cache), they are incredibly fast, comparing to a WD 74gb raptor in most cases. They are also much quieter than past maxtors I have owned.
 
MAxtors tend to have a higher fail rate than some other drives, but they are also a tadchepaer sometimes. I woul dprobably go with Seagte (that's what I have now). They are pretty cheap (comparable to the rest at least), have decent performance, have excellent warranties and low fail rates, and they run very quiet... WD is also pretty good, but I would just go for the better price and warranty...
 
I own 2 maxtors, 1 seagate and 1 WD. none of them have competely crapped out on me, but the seagate has begun to shown it's age as it's noticeably slower and noiser than the rest of the bunch.
 
the difference between PATA and SATA isn't really important, as no modern hard drives really reach the maximum transfer rate (be it 133 or 150) anyway. However, because the raptor is 10,000, it might be better to get it. I have one, and it's not that loud. All 2005 WD drives have FDBs, too.
 
Depending on their price and performance, I'd get any WDs, Hitachis, Seagate, Maxtors, since I've yet to encounter any problem from any of them (I've been lucky, I suppose) 🙂
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

TRENDING THREADS

Back
Top