Halo 2 Review

VIAN

Diamond Member
Aug 22, 2003
6,575
1
0
[The Good]
There are lots of ammo consuming enemies to kill and plenty of checkpoints along the way.

[The Bad]
Halo 2 is disappointing compared to its predecessor. It is slow paced and can be very repetitive at times.

[Single-player Review]
STORY
Halo 2 continues the adventure started by Halo: CE (Halo: Combat Evolved). But this time, instead of focusing on just Master Chief, 50% of the game is played with the Arbiter from the Covenant. You alternate between them throughout a detailed, but unmotivating story. They eventually cross paths and find out that they have a common enemy: religious politics. And to many players, it ends abruptly. The reason for this is that Halo 2 set up so much interesting material for Halo 3 that it became confusing in comparison to Halo 2?s material.

One of the things that really bothered me was how small the battle on earth was. I was looking forward to a massive, open ended battle; as what it looked like in some of the videos released on the internet. Outside earth, sure looked mean, I would?ve imagined the inside to look worse, but it wasn?t so. The level also didn?t feel like earth. The design was too bulky and simple, a common occurrence in the outdoor levels of Halo 2.

GAMEPLAY
One of the things that made Halo: CE so great was the big, outdoor environments and freedom to walk around, practically anywhere. Bungie doesn?t bring this to Halo 2. Instead, most levels are enclosed, linear. Bungie makes things worse by having impractically elaborated, and repetitive interior level designs. And the outdoor levels are scarcely decorated, having just simple shapes. The earth level is an example of this. It doesn't even look earthly, except for the palm trees. Because of these, the game becomes tedious often. And levels sometimes have objectives like: Get through the flood Infested Wall. It?s basically telling me that I'm only going through here just to shoot stuff. Objectives like that are boring. And there are a few of them like that, showcasing the repetitiveness of the game.

The combat is the most fun part of the game. You get to play with various fun weapons, both earthy and alien. And now you can dual-wield weapons, which is awsome, especially with the SMG. The only problem with this is that some weapons take up quite a big portion of the screen. But generally it?s fun.

The vehicles however are disappointing. You never get the freedom to use a vehicle the way its predecessor allowed. Halo: CE had vehicles laying around for you to use if you wanted to. Halo 2 expects you to use them and creates sections in the game specifically for their use. If you don?t use them, those sections either become boring or impossible to finish.

A lot of the old enemies return, as expected, but some new ones are introduced: hairy, big-foot creatures and annoying fly things. The fly things appear once in a while. They don?t cause too much damage and don?t take too many hits to kill, but they do move around a lot. The big-foot dudes, called Brutes, on the other hand, take so long to kill and consume a lot of ammo. During the second half of the game, you fight the Brutes so often that it becomes tiresome. At times it seems to slow down the pace of the game. And the fact that they all look alike kills the variety of the game.

?which brings me to the AI. It doesn?t seem as smart in this sequel, if you hide, it won?t come and find you, in fact, the enemy is probably hiding himself and will stay that way until you come at them. They stand around doing nothing and never surprise you. It?s like the AI is only activated, with delay, once it sees you. I don?t remember it being like this in Halo: CE.

GRAPHICS
The graphics are a little disappointing. The shaders are updated, as you can see with the water effects. But some things just aren?t up to par with its predecessor. I remember approaching a rock in Halo: CE and noticing that it was sharply detailed. You could see every nook and cranny. It?s not the same in Halo 2 however. Some textures, such as in the earth level, look plain, as if a wall were only a solid color. I also fail to see bump mapping in many of the levels containing designs imprinted on metal walls. This is very disappointing considering the smaller level designs in Halo 2.

One thing that didn?t change, the cut-scenes are just horrible to look at sometimes, sporting low res. textures and poly counts that look years behind their time.

[Verdict]
2/4 Poor Value (7.0 ? 7.9) The Halo 2 single-player campaign is a poor value to be purchased at premium price and possibly even to waste your time with. It?s too tedious to play through the disappointing campaign. I would recommend this game only for fans of the series so that they could follow the story. They might also have some fun with all the killing. But new players to the series should check out Halo: CE, if they want a good Halo experience.
 

Kromis

Diamond Member
Mar 2, 2006
5,214
1
81
In my opinion, the first Halo sucked ass. The levels designs repeat themselves ad nauseum. I get a headache and feel like barfing. Halo 2 is *much* better than Halo: CE because of updated graphics as well as more gameplay mechanics. Online too!

And you say there's no mystery to the Halo 2 story? What about Cortana and the Gravemind? What about that Halo 3 trailer that we saw at E3? Apparently, the Gravemind has done something to Cortana!
 

KeithTalent

Elite Member | Administrator | No Lifer
Administrator
Nov 30, 2005
50,231
118
116
Heh, I'm just about to fire up Halo CE for the PC...and I can hardly wait!

I love this game (MP only) and I have never understood all the naysayers...it's great!!!!

Looking forward to Halo2 with DX10!
 

Zenoth

Diamond Member
Jan 29, 2005
5,198
204
106
I loved Halo: Combat Evolved, and I still play it sometimes (PC version, much better than XBOX because of controls mostly, and more detailed textures). I really liked Halo 2 until I found out that the Legendary mode for it was nothing compared to Halo: CE's Legendary. And those damn Jackal Snipers (in Halo 2) on Legendary kill you right on, 1-hit-kill, they never miss, and that believe me was a show stopper for me. Overall I preferred the original, but Halo 2 is still a good game, I was just quite disappointed by the Legendary mode (not just because of the Jackal Snipers, there were other reasons).

And since I do not own any Console at the moment I don't know if I'll be interested in Halo 3 once it will be released (sometime in 2007, right ? I presume during the holidays). Maybe I'll buy a 360 just for it ... don't know, I'll see. Or else I'm going to wait for a PC version.

Once Halo 2 is released along with Vista I'm gonna get it, and edit the stupid perfect Jackal Snipers accuracy and damage, so that I can take 2 hits, one for the shield, and then another to die. Not just one, it takes out the whole fun, and since the camera suddenly went looking in all directions when killed by a single shot you never had the time to actually see where the shot came from, so you kept dying and dying until your next guess was the lucky one. Very frustrating stuff for me. I know that's subjective, but that alone was almost enough to return the game.
 

tuteja1986

Diamond Member
Jun 1, 2005
3,676
0
0
I love Halo 1 and Halo 2 for its storyline. Some times the game gets boring but i keep playing on just to know what happens next. I also like the halo books.
 

juiio

Golden Member
Feb 28, 2000
1,433
4
81
Originally posted by: Zenoth
I loved Halo: Combat Evolved, and I still play it sometimes (PC version, much better than XBOX because of controls mostly, and more detailed textures). I really liked Halo 2 until I found out that the Legendary mode for it was nothing compared to Halo: CE's Legendary. And those damn Jackal Snipers (in Halo 2) on Legendary kill you right on, 1-hit-kill, they never miss, and that believe me was a show stopper for me. Overall I preferred the original, but Halo 2 is still a good game, I was just quite disappointed by the Legendary mode (not just because of the Jackal Snipers, there were other reasons).

What do you mean that Legendary on 2 is nothing compared to Legendary on 1? Do you think it is easier? It isn't really any easier or harder, you're just better at the game now. Halo 1 on Legendary isn't particularly hard the second time you play through it.

BTW, the snipers aren't always one-hit kill and they do miss. There also aren't really that many of them in the game. Just a couple levels that have them at all.

I don't really like the solo campaign on 2 compared to 1, but I don't really think either of your complaints are particularly valid, though.
 

jim1976

Platinum Member
Aug 7, 2003
2,704
6
81
I loved the first HALO in my PC. I haven't touched HALO 2 yet though... Looking forward to it in PC..
 

Ika

Lifer
Mar 22, 2006
14,264
3
81
I loved Halo CE a lot (I've replayed Halo PC too many times), but killing enemies was very tedious (especially the flood... bah!). Sometimes it was fun, but just last night, I fired up legendary on the Pillar of Autumn and I was getting mauled. I finally switched to plasma pistol/pistol combo and could kill elites... but every single elite had to fall in basically the same way - hide, charge up a plasma bolt, fire it, wait for the elite to stand back up, and nail him in the head with the pistol. I love the storyline, though, and I always watch the cutscenes.

Halo 2 felt very different, and the storyline was definitely NOT as appealing, but I liked it just as much. This time, it was mainly because the weapon choices were more balanced - you weren't ALWAYS using this weapon or that one; you could pick up any odd weapon and it would suit you just fine (carbine, battle rifle, magnum/plasma pistol dual-wield, dual needlers, smg + plasma rifle combo, etc etc etc). Gameplay was much more open-ended and I think that would make Halo 2 less repetitive to replay (I played it over about 3 times, with the same level of enjoyment). However, I didn't like the no-health system, because it meant less health management (and a change in your overall strategy). The vehicle choices were good, except that the gauss warthog was next to IMPOSSIBLE to find and use (me and a friend finally obtained one on the big flood level, after about 50 reloads). All in all, Halo 2 was a fun game that I would want to own.