Originally posted by: TheVrolok
Originally posted by: CZroe
Absolutely NOT. I targeted stability and important usability issues. Not "pet peeves." As for those, the things Vista changed either worsened them or improved/added something every bit as unimportant as you pretend UI and stability are.
File copy dialogs still pop up, steal focus, and cancel when you are typing (due to hitting the space button). The primary click still sometimes gets stuck like an alt-click until you alt-click. Just like the Start Menu organizing before Vista overhauled it, these quirks have existed since Win95 and still haven't been fixed. Other than the Start Menu overhaul inadvertently fixing the interactivity problems that existed since the IE4 Desktop update for Win 95, Vista has NEW quirks without fixing, well, anything. OK, one more inadvertent "fix." My my brother and I discovered a data loss bug in Paint that has existed since Win 95 and they finally updated it (reproducible bug where "Save" would enable but your specific edits would not save), so that glitch is probably gone.
So here you're Vista failure is that dialog boxes pop up while you're not watching (I guess you're staring at the keyboard as your type or reading the copy while you're transcribing) and you accidentally hit spacebar to cancel? I can't say I frequently have this problem, in fact, I can't even remember the last time this happened. And while I'm sure it may have happened one or two times in the past year, I can say that if a new dialog box DIDN'T take focus I'd have many more instances of frustration. Far more frequently do I wait for a box to popup so I can read the information and hit space to cast it away. Popup windows are SUPPOSED to take focus to alert the user of something that's happening. Can you imagine how many people would completely miss them if they didn't? OS failure? No
Originally posted by: CZroe
DX11 was an arbitrary exclusive at the expense of continuing to treat certain products independent of the OS (WMP, IE, and DX11)... as arbitrary as making a DX8 port, Halo 2, exclusive to it. Understandably, they have allowed XP to depreciate to push Vista, but the least they could have done was include the latest IE and WMP when SP3 went gold. Instead, you get SP2 level browser and Media Player exploits out of the box despite years of updates to those bundled, but independent products in the interim. DX is no longer independent and I've relegated myself to that, so I'm not going to bitch and moan about Win7/DX11, but there really was no excuse for the SP3 IE/WMP business.
I'm not sure exactly what you're whining about here. My XP laptop is running IE8 and WMP11 with just slightly lower build numbers than my Vista desktop, which would seem to me that they've stayed on a fairly level playing field. I admit, I'm no expert in IE/WMP because I haven't used either for years but I'm not seeing a huge discrepancy either.
Originally posted by: CZroe
0 problem, eh? So, you're saying that Vista has never crashed on you? You've never had to force it off? You've used it daily since early 2007? Bullshit.
I would say I've had maybe 10 total crashes since Nov '07 (when I built this system and installed Vista). Of those 10, I can tell you that 2 or so came from bad drivers (beta versions), and at LEAST 5 came from OC attempts that left my system very unstable. There may have been 1 or 2 that just came out of no where, but honestly, I can't even remember when my system last crashed (now that I'm using a good set of drivers and my OC is stable). Call bullshit if you want, or maybe you're just exaggerating how unstable you think Vista is.
Originally posted by: CZroe
As for pushing the Windows key, in case you didn't notice, I said that they have the EXACT same problem there. You don't work in a call center, do you? Yes, they are a minority of callers, but there are enough that you would encounter them more than once. You can even tell them that it is the key between "CTRL/Control and ALT/Alternate on the area to the left of the spacebar (after confirming that they are on a desktop PC) and they will insist that there is nothing there like you describe (Windows flag/logo).
Please tell me how user stupidity is a flaw of the OS. You're going to tell me it's MS' fault that certain humans are so obtuse that they can't locate a button on their keyboard? Come on man.
Originally posted by: CZroe
And the Document folder names are a long-time Windows pet peeve... not related to Vista. All I said was that they didn't fix it. I even implied that it was too late to fix it and that they should have done it long ago with the switch to XP. My point was that they made things worse when they made similar changes that will throw a user off and yet they didn't take the opportunity to fix other things that are easy to do. IOW, an instructional document can no longer refer to "Start" button, "MY" Computer or "My" Pictures and expect the user to follow along on both OSes.