I guess I'm predictable.
Piano Performance will be my recommendation (I've been warned off from Music Ed and Pedagogy is apparently only offered at the graduate level).
Yes, I live in the suburbs of Chicago.
Music? Why aren't you applying to any specific music schools?
a) Those things are harder than hell to get into, they're expensive as hell, they're really far away (hell). Causing them to get even more expensive.
b) I'm a people-person, and want a large and diverse student population. Also, although I doubt this will happen, what if I decide music isn't working out? I'd like to have the option to go other places career-wise, not because I'm expecting to, but just because the option is there. I also just plain ol' want to experience college. And some well-roundedness is good, whereas if I go to a conservatory, no more science or math or anything except music after high school. As inviting as that sounds, I think I might regret that in the long run.
EDIT: despite all this, I am in fact planning at auditioning at a few conservatories (Julliard, Oberlin, Eastman, etc). But that's just for kicks, and if I get into any of em, then I can mull it over.