• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Good computer speakers?

I'd like to get a set of external speakers for my laptop, simply to listen to some music while I'm working. What are good sounding speakers... not too big, nothing crazy. Good quality. Can anyone recommend?

The source would of course be my output sound jack on my laptop.
 
My sister is quite happy with the small Bose 2.1 set, which isn't that expensive and has a very convenient little control device. Can't say that that they sound bad, agreeable footprint on the table, the sub-woofer is somewhat largish.
My other sister isn't unhappy with an older mid-end Logitech (X-530? could be something like that) 2.1 set. I don't think you can do anything wrong by going for something in the 80-150$ range. They're all pretty decent, and as you go higher, you usually get some more features or slightly better balanced sound. Below the 80$ mark things may get a bit dodgier, but that doesn't mean that some marked down old stock may be a good deal.

With laptop sound cards there's no point in going for anything beyond those 150$, as these things are usually not excellent.
 
are you just leaving the speakers there or are you going to move them? Budget?


PS do not buy Bose.
 
In general I'd recommend a 2.0 set such as the Audioengines above.

In my personal experience, Behringer MS40 offers sound quality way above its price; they are cheaper than the Audioengines. MS40 has optical in so if your laptop can output that, all the better - you won't be at the mercy of a potentially noisy headphone port.
 
Amazing how many people recommend the A2, I wonder if you actually heard them or not.

OP, if you do choose to go with the A2, be aware that almost nothing below 100Hz comes out of them, which is a huge problem. You need a hefty boost on all frequencies up to 80Hz for them to sound anything close to normal.

Of course that makes them clip and fart like crazy if you raise the volume, and it's normal, after all that's all a 2.75" driver can handle, but for medium volume listening they are okay after equalization. The silk dome tweeter on the other hand actually handles high frequencies pretty well.

For the money they are pretty good value considering they are active speakers, but without equalization they sound terrible.
 
do not buy Bose.

Why not?
With such small speakers psycho-acoustics matter, and that's an area where Bose's shine.

And WTF 400 dollars a pair speakers!

This is for a laptop headphone exit, not an external DAC.

Anything above 120 is probably overkill. (Seeing the price on the Companion 3s that does mean those are out as well. There's a used unit someone is selling for 150 on amazon though. At sticker price they're not good enough.)

Whether 2.0 or 2.1 depends on intended use. Music probably benefits more from a decent stereo set, but most movies and games ought to sound more enjoyable from a 2.1 system.
 
Why not?
With such small speakers psycho-acoustics matter, and that's an area where Bose's shine.

Psycho-BS. A good speaker reproduces all frequencies taking into account that:

1. Humans eardrums are less sensitive to certain frequencies than measuring equipment, so crossover tuning is very important.

2. The environment may have adverse effects on certain frequencies more than others, so it is important to go back to point 1 and tune for the most common environment and materials within the environment.

3. Certain frequencies are just difficult to reproduce based on size of the driver, quality of materials, and manufacturing process.


Bose fails all three.


1. Physics. It is impossible to tune a crossover for a 2" dynamic driver to be accurate at all frequencies. Pointing a subwoofer in single direction is not the answer.

2. They create their own environment everywhere their products are sold, and this is mandatory. i don't know anybody who's room allows them to have 5 speakers surrounding their head...

3. Refer back to 1.



And the same can be said about the Audioengine A2, but at least they are better than Bose at step 3. They still fall short at step 1 because of dimension restrictions.

If you look at what Garfield suggested, you'll see that 3/4 speakers sport a 5" driver. The A2 is a bastard child that can be tuned to sound half decent for those with little space.
 
Yeah, even the Behringer MS40 I recommended have 4.75" woofers + separate tweeters. Bigger doesn't necessarily sound better, but it's hard to make something really small sound good.
 
Why not?
With such small speakers psycho-acoustics matter, and that's an area where Bose's shine.

And WTF 400 dollars a pair speakers!

This is for a laptop headphone exit, not an external DAC.

Anything above 120 is probably overkill. (Seeing the price on the Companion 3s that does mean those are out as well. There's a used unit someone is selling for 150 on amazon though. At sticker price they're not good enough.)

Whether 2.0 or 2.1 depends on intended use. Music probably benefits more from a decent stereo set, but most movies and games ought to sound more enjoyable from a 2.1 system.


the rokit5 can be had for 300 a pair. And these are real speakers, not plastic toys.

Fact is many of the white van speakers are better than Bose.

And generally speaking the analogue outs of laptops are decent. USB sound cards are available if op decides to upgrade. I doubt there is a need.

http://www.amazon.com/KRK-Studio-Ref...rds=krk+rokit5

317 for a pair of rokit5, 2 xlr cables and stands.
 
Last edited:
the rokit5 can be had for 300 a pair. And these are real speakers, not plastic toys.

If you find the right deal you can get the Rokit6's for 300 a pair. I picked up some rokit8's with stands and foam pads for 400.

I suggest the Rokit6's or the AE5's.
 
Maximum PC just gave the A5 a kickass award... Apparently it has a 50 watt class AB amp and the boxes have built in bass chambers that apparently give the 5" kevler woofers some punch. I find it hard to believe that a 5" driver can produce lows but... I've never heard them but for 400 bucks they better be good.

🙂
 

Yeah, that's for the high-end stuff, which I wouldn't touch. (My ignorant brother got sucked in and got a 2.1 system - which is okay, but not nearly worth the money. Don't think he paid full price, but still way too much)

the smaller stuff, if you get a deal is actually reasonably good for a 2.1 computer setup. And the little volume control thing looks nice, works well, and is convenient. Something that not many get right.

Also, while not B&O design, it does look better than the Logitech and Creative sets, if you were to care about such things.
Anyway, I can't defend the list price of these either, but for half-price they become an option.

This looks like a good compromise at 120 dollars: http://www.edifier-international.com/products/edifier-multimedia/s330-s330d
 
Back
Top