Originally posted by: dullard
Originally posted by: mchammer187
why even participate in an activity that you view is a net loss either way then?
surely it isn't mandatory and if it is than I would concede that you have a very valid point
Economics textbooks list Christmas as one of the biggest net losses because people pay tons of money for items that others value very little. Buying things is, of course, good for the economy; however, buying things often is a net loss for the gift giver/receiver pair.
That doesn't mean though that gift giving should be ended. No, it just means that giving isn't about opening up a wallet and forking over money to a retailer. Giving is about adding net value. Give someone something that costs you little and what is priceless to them.
I'll try an example. About a year ago I made a post for a gift for my then brand new GF
(link). GF loves a cheap mac & cheese that she couldn't buy in this country. I eventually got someone on ATOT to buy me that brand in Canada for next to nothing, shipped it to me, and I gave it to her. A few bucks bought well over a year of joy for her. She still savors that case of mac & cheese I bought. She still glows when she tells the story of how her new BF found out exactly what she wanted and couldn't get and then went through all the trouble to get it for her and for no reason at all (it wasn't even close to Christmas, a holiday, or her birthday). I spent a few bucks, and she got hundreds of dollars of value from it.
How did it work? I took the time, I took the effort, I took on the challenge of secretly finding out the one item that she really wanted the most. It is that effort that added to the value of the gift. Randomly asking strangers what to give as a gift to another stranger is about the exact opposite.
A common phrase is that the joy of Christmas is about giving not receiving. But in reality, the joy of Christmas is about getting to know someone well enough that he/she will enjoy the gift you select. THAT is why you give gifts. If you won't/can't do all of that, then give cash as it is the best of the rest of the options.