Garage workshop feasibility questions

Status
Not open for further replies.

mazeroth

Golden Member
Jan 31, 2006
1,821
2
81
I have a 20w x 24d garage that's a little too cramped for my liking. I would like to add an addition onto the back of the garage the same 20w and probably 16 deep. Right now my garage is used for parking my wife's car as well as my weight lifting equipment and general storage. We have a very small ranch; so small that my computer desk is in the basement next to the furnace! The addition I add I would like to have a poured concrete floor, very well insulated (unlike my current garage) and heated and cooled via a mini split that will run off 120v 20A. I'll put all my weight equipment back there, my computer, and anything else that will make it a comfy spot for me to get away from the wife and kids and do my thing.

I'm a very handy guy, having completely gutted and remodeled our entire house. Taking out walls, redoing 2 bathrooms, installing hardwood floors, kitchen cabinets, and putting on 25 squares of shingles. I did have a framer help me with the framing and I know a drywaller so I didn't touch that stuff. I would be paying for someone to pour the slab, to do all the framing (tie new roof into old as well), siding and my buddy to do the drywall. I will do the electrical, insulation and roofing. Ok, now onto my questions.

We only have 0.25 acres so a detached is not an option. If you look at the pictures below you will get a pretty good idea of what I'm working with. Please excuse the mess on the back patio as I've been super busy with work and remodeling to care about cleaning that up! My main concerns are tying this new addition into the existing garage. My current garage has 10' ceilings. I would be fine with 8-8.5' ceilings in the addition so that I can tie the existing roof into this one. I will not be able to keep the same roof pitch to maintain my desired ceiling height. Will this be a problem?

The main problem areas are where the garage attaches to the house. Is this going to be an issue where the house soffit overhangs a little bit, or will the framers have no problem fixing this?

Also, on the left where the garage gutter goes down into the current slab (that slab will be taken out), I don't think it's going to be a major issue extending the gutter drain back 16 feet and tying into the new gutter. Thoughts?

For the siding on the left, will I need to take some pieces out for the new siding to tie in so it will look like one long wall, or will I be able to leave that 90 degree piece in there?

Any other glaring faults in this plan? I'm hoping to keep the total cost under $10,000. Crazy?

Thanks!

14346935736_095246dff3_o.jpg


14183396229_41f293c16b_o.jpg


14369119294_b92e1fdd98_o.jpg


14183577767_54ae40f53f_o.jpg


14183393199_c6bd9be02b_o.jpg
 
Last edited:

olds

Elite Member
Mar 3, 2000
50,129
781
126
Seems pretty straight forward. Tying into the existing roof and flashing it would scare me off from doing that section on my own.
 

Carson Dyle

Diamond Member
Jul 2, 2012
8,173
524
126
The main problem areas are where the garage attaches to the house. Is this going to be an issue where the house soffit overhangs a little bit, or will the framers have no problem fixing this?

That does look a little tricky. I wonder if they could also extend the garage roof at the same pitch for another foot or so, to the edge of the house, before the new roof comes off with a flatter pitch. I would ask whoever is going to do the work. I'd definitely get someone who knows what he's doing when it comes to remodels, not just a couple of mouth-breathers who do framing in new construction.

Also, on the left where the garage gutter goes down into the current slab (that slab will be taken out), I don't think it's going to be a major issue extending the gutter drain back 16 feet and tying into the new gutter. Thoughts?
What does it drain into? Can't you just drain into the yard where you are?

For the siding on the left, will I need to take some pieces out for the new siding to tie in so it will look like one long wall, or will I be able to leave that 90 degree piece in there?

Obviously you can't leave the 90 degree corner piece if your wall will be flush, but you could leave a vertical piece, which should be OK visually and will make siding the extension easier.
 

Greenman

Lifer
Oct 15, 1999
22,497
6,582
136
Keep the ceiling heights the same or you'll have a step in the roof. The corner you're concerned about doesn't matter at all. I don't understand the siding question, won't that corner be butted into a new wall?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.