Gameboy SP vs. XBox (vs. Shuttle XPC) Advice?

Incitatus

Member
Jun 29, 2003
74
0
0
I have a limited amount of cash to blow and I'm weighing the pros and cons of my options.

I've wanted a "media" box to play "console" games on, old emu. arcade games, watch movies, etc., so I was thinking of going with Shuttle's tiny nforce2 400 ultra box. Then I thought, hey, for the same price (~$325) I could get an XBox and soup it up to play mp3s, videos, console games, etc. etc. I had never really thought about buying an xbox until a few days ago, but it is sounding like it does exactly what I originally wanted my tiny-PC/shuttle to do, except be designed specifically for the job and not tie up my personal box.

Then of course enters a third element: the Gameboy SP. For ~$225 I get everything I need for the lifetime of the device. Due to a recent shift in leisure lifestyle, I'm finding myself sitting in airport terminals, on planes, in subways, etc. Family summer vacation is coming up, and it is featuring both flights and roadtrips. (It certainly wasn't my idea. No, I'm not driving.)

So I guess my decision has been narrowed down a bit to XBox vs. GBSP. I've never even played a GBA/SP before, and I'm not really aware of the whole scene. I hear it is amazing, though. I've never played XBox for more than 20 minutes, and I'm fairily "up" with the scene of things, so I'm confident it wouldn't go to waste.

I guess it all comes down to the question: is GBSP merely an expensive time-eater or is it a contender with enthralling games? Should I suck it up and read some good books through travelling downtime or would a GBSP pay itself off in the long run? (Over, say, an Xbox?)

I realize this is sort of an Apples/Oranges deal. I have almost zero experience with either of my contenders so I'm looking here for some guidance. Thanks :)
 

Yzzim

Lifer
Feb 13, 2000
11,990
1
76
Originally posted by: bleeb
Get a GameCube. XCrap sucks.

Xbox + modchip + bigger hdd = more games, emus, mp3s, divx, and so much more.

That's coming from a guy who owns both the Xbox and Gamecube.

Get an Xbox, mod it, and you'll be happy.

Used Xbox = $150 (at most)
cheapmod = $20
bigger hdd = $50-$100 (up to you)

Total of $220-$270 for a very fun (and very flexable) machine
 

clicknext

Banned
Mar 27, 2002
3,884
0
0
I wouldn't count on the performance of the shuttle box to play games well. If you really want to play games the way they're meant to be played get an Xbox or other console. (I'd recommend PS2, but that's just personal preference, and I don't think it does what you want anyway.)

GBSP is plenty fun travelling around on a plane or something, but in my opinion is that it's not good enough to entertain you when you're sitting at home on a day with some free time.

What I would do is get a console, and when you're travelling just read books or listen to music or something.
 

Koing

Elite Member <br> Super Moderator<br> Health and F
Oct 11, 2000
16,843
2
0
You are going to spend $225 on a GameBoy SP? What else you going to get with it? I would get the XBox and upgrade your pc a bit. Surely your pc can play some games?

What types of games are you interested in?

Koing
 

Narse

Moderator<br>Computer Help
Moderator
Mar 14, 2000
3,826
1
81
A moded xbox is the way to go, It plays Gameboy, Super Nintendo and much More. It can play DVDs DIVX Files. Its the best investment I ever made.
 

Incitatus

Member
Jun 29, 2003
74
0
0
Originally posted by: Koing
You are going to spend $225 on a GameBoy SP? What else you going to get with it?

The, uh, "developer tools."

The shuttle would hardly be "under powered" .. this isn't a VIA ITX, this is a Shuttle nForce2; dual channel DDR, 400 FSB (Barton), 8x AGP (GF FX), etc. Though at this point I'm leaning Xbox.

I haven't had a console since N64 days. It sort of left a bad flavor in my mouth, I guess. A few games were fun, but overall it was a dissapointment. Perhaps an XBox will kick my ass back in gear.

What XBox mod chip would you guys recommend? I've general overviews but I don't know the specifics/nittygritty.
 

BennyD

Banned
Sep 1, 2002
2,068
0
0
Originally posted by: Narse
A moded xbox is the way to go, It plays Gameboy, Super Nintendo and much More. It can play DVDs DIVX Files. Its the best investment I ever made.

thats not really the point, he already knows that, an xbox is about as portable as a scrotum.... nailed to a tree.

he wants to know whether the SP will be used or just end up as a bookend

i think the SP will be a godsend ona long trip

just ask yourself will you be at home more or travelling more?

also you can play games at home on your pc
 

Dragnov

Diamond Member
Apr 24, 2001
6,878
0
0
Gameboy Advance SP rules.

Secret of Mana and Final Fantasy Tactics coming out real soon. I need money!