- Sep 25, 2001
why did the Treasurer guy lie about the dagger being Tyrions?I think you are wrong about Catelyn.
She doesn't hate John, she resents him because he is a reminder of Ned's cheating.
She kidnapped Tyrion because she was led to believe that he tried to kill her son.
And the war started the second Robert dies and Catelyn had nothing to do with that either.