G3 thru G7 Xeon/ECC/Discrete Graphics ZBooks: Noisy Even Under Light Loads?

chane

Member
Apr 18, 2010
107
9
81
I'm very badly overdue for a new laptop; embarrassed to say how old my Sony laptop is. But as I want to absolutely minimize bit errors, it’s sensible to choose ECC memory over non-ECC memory. But ECC RAM is only supported by motherboards supporting Xeon (and some AMD?) processors.

However, a noisy laptop is not acceptable, and I’ve read that Xeon based laptops can be noisy. But under all load conditions? I never play games and the most resource hungry tasks would probably be occasionally playing 1080p youtube videos. Most tasks would be downloading youtubes, MS Office, shopping and backing up to a multi drive NAS or server with ECC RAM; Synology or Qnap.

I'd like this laptop to last ten years so I don't too much mind paying ~ $2100. for a well built one with a 15" screen that stays very cool and quiet for all the above tasks.

And will it tend to stay cooler/quieter with discrete graphics on motherboard rather than with Xeon processors with on-chip graphics and enabled?

Will Xeon/ECC G3 thru G7 Zbooks-or identically equipped Lenovo or Dell model laptops-be as quiet as most consumer laptops under these kinds of loads? Or does this kind of hardware usually mean a noisier laptop in any case-even when just idling, though hardly the kind of performance one would think those with normal hearing would pay > $2K for.
 

aigomorla

CPU, Cases&Cooling Mod PC Gaming Mod Elite Member
Super Moderator
Sep 28, 2005
20,781
3,075
126
I'd like this laptop to last ten years

no.. half your budget please then and upgrade every 3 yrs....
nothing and i say nothing in tech lasts 10 yrs anymore.
We are not back in the 80's where things were built like ford tough...
Its now "fast and fragile", so you need to rebuy and the company can stay in business.

backing up to a multi drive NAS or server with ECC RAM; Synology or Qnap.

why would you do this on a laptop?
You use a NAS to backup another NAS or a SAN, because or storage space reasons.
Just get a surface pro IMO @ bestbuys when they go on crazy sale and think of getting one every 3-4 yrs.... that is what i do now, and i am coming from a long time user in HP Elitebooks because i thought they could last even 5 yrs, when it didn't last 3.
 

VirtualLarry

No Lifer
Aug 25, 2001
55,989
9,873
126
no.. half your budget please then and upgrade every 3 yrs....
nothing and i say nothing in tech lasts 10 yrs anymore.
We are not back in the 80's where things were built like ford tough...
Its now "fast and fragile", so you need to rebuy and the company can stay in business.

and i am coming from a long time user in HP Elitebooks because i thought they could last even 5 yrs, when it didn't last 3.
I had this discussion with someone today. They thought that I owned too many (semi-budget, say $200-300) laptops, and that I should get rid of a few, and save up, for "one good one".

While the more expensive ones are often a little bit better-built (looking at you, business laptops with magnesium chassis, or aluminum), I still prefer the multiple-laptop shotgun approach to longevity.
 
  • Like
Reactions: aigomorla

aigomorla

CPU, Cases&Cooling Mod PC Gaming Mod Elite Member
Super Moderator
Sep 28, 2005
20,781
3,075
126
Tech and battery advanmcements are too great now.
So even a 3yr old laptop has a significant disadvantage over battery life and power.

And lets not even forget its only taken AMD 4 yrs to topple intel with Ryzen.