NFS4
No Lifer
Ups: Eye-catching design, forgiving ride quality, hardtop convenience, nearly every feature is standard.
Downs: Interior doesn't always reflect the price, not as sporty as its Corvette underpinnings might suggest, minimal cargo space, can be cramped for taller drivers.
The Bottom Line: Its design makes it stand out from the crowd, but its performance and craftsmanship aren't quite as extraordinary.
Full Test: 2004 Cadillac XLR