"the R8500 consumes less power then the GF3/4 Ti series.... the reg. R8500's power consumption is in-line with the GF4 MX460 in 3D, and the MX440 in 2D."
Yeah sure, and the tech support board at Rage3d isn't full of guys being told to buy higher watt psus to cure their problem with lockups...
I had an R8500 in a box with a 250watt psu that ran a GF3 original and a GF4 4400, flawlessly, day in day out.
My Radeon 8500 retail, on the other hand would lock up for no apparent reason while playing games. Hmmmm. What could it be?
Temperature? Nope. This box is in my basement, where the air temp is never more than 70f, it's a full tower with a front fan sucking air in, two in back pushing it out. My cpu is always cool....hmmmmm...
How about driver conflict? Nah, couldn't be that. Fdisk/format. IRQ conflict? Nope, everything had it's own. PCI next to AGP? Nope. Latest 4in1s? Nope. Latest bios for motherboard (Epox 8KHA+)? Nope. Drivers for the 8500? Nope, tried lots, and they were pretty mature by the time I tried the 8500 early this year.
What could the answer to this mystery be? After 5 years in IT/IS, I think I can install a VGA- at least it worked the other 100 times I've done it. But you're probably right- "disinformation alert". The R8500 is the most trouble free card to hit the planet, no matter what hardware you have. And the GF3/GF4 ran fine for months before and after , with no tweaking whatsoever, because I got special boards sprinkled with pixie dust that even an oaf like me could install.
Excuse me, I have to warm up my Van der Graaf generators so I can pass some RAM DIMMs through the electrical arc between them before installation......