Friends or "more than friends" how to go about it?

DannyLove

Lifer
Oct 17, 2000
12,876
4
76
HI, I'm just going to go straight to the point.

I've only been in three serious relationships in my life(other times i'm slutting away), where I've fallen in love on the last two girls. In those relationships I've met by simply going up to them and asking them out, or through her/my friends. In other words, the interest and attraction was already established and we took it from there. However, during the last year I found myself in a different situation. The situation of being their friend. I've been single for almost a year and during that year i've created lots a girl - friends (notice the seperation) and we've all had fun going to movies, chillin, ya know, being friends. Keep in mind i've never went into any relationship based on a complete friendship, all the other times I automatically felt attracted to such a person and went from there, but this particular situation had me thinking.

When is it right to pursue the friendship line and try and boost it beyond that line. One girl in particular; We were friends and we knew each other for a while since she was going out with a roommate of mine. We were great together as friends, and i loved her for that. She's a great person and we had this really strong friendship, until we began to have feelings for each other. When I began to feel attracted to her I felt strange approaching the situation and didn't exactly know what to do. At this moment we didn't reveil this "secret" and always talked to other friends in dealing with the subject. I felt that it was wrong to feel for her, since its of high risk. Its like placing a high bet on the tabel with high value and every move you make after that will determine if or not you'll win the hand. Unfortunately, I lost the hand in this case. After we "reveiled" to each other how we felt, it dissolved because we couldn't really do the same "friendship" events without questioning or feeling strange about it. As the decline took place, I was completely pissed at myself, because i felt i screwed up in telling her my true feelings.

Current situation is that she has a boyfriend and I've completely lost all interest in pursuing the "more than friends approach." That part of me has been completely turned off since she only gave herself a couple weeks in forgeting the whole awkward friends/more and ending up having a "boyfriend." This pretty much led me to believe that her feelings weren't as strong as mine, since she completely changed gears in a matter of weeks. Now our friendship isn't what it used to be which leeds me to conclude that this is SUCK! :(

Now, im in a similar situation again. I've thought and thought about it, and I've decided that I will not pursue. What do you think?

In these examples, I've showed the flaw in pursuing the "more friends" approach which leeds me to question it.

Anyone been in a similar situation, and actually had success? I guess i should just leave my friends as friends and find other girls out there. But then that means i have to start all over in knowing someone, this sucks!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Thanks guys :)
DannyLove (currently no "love" at the moment :()
 

Turkey

Senior member
Jan 10, 2000
839
0
0
I was best friends with a girl once. After we'd known each other for a little over a year, we started dating and that lasted for about about a year. We broke up, and she found a new boyfriend in about a month, which I thought was a little weird. Now she's engaged to the guy, but we're still pretty close friends and I'm doing her guestbook for her wedding. Our friendship isn't like it was before, but she's still one of my best friends, mainly because she's really good with communicating with people she likes. We both know that neither of us is interested in the other, because she's engaged and I was the one who started the breakup. With that understanding, we're all good.
 

DannyLove

Lifer
Oct 17, 2000
12,876
4
76
kuk: sorry but my situation is a little different. geez, i guess no one cares. and no its not a post-valentine thing. happened a while back
 

Namuna

Platinum Member
Jun 20, 2000
2,435
1
0
The 'just friends' into 'more than just friends' route is tricky at best!

There's no hard and fast rules here, though I was readin an article in Maxim that had some great hints you could throw at a potential 'more than just friends' girl.

But no matter what, you're gambling at it.

I've had a long time 'just friend' and she's great, and while I AM attracted to her I will never approach her in that way because I place our friendship VERY high and wouldn't jeopardize that. But I do fell that somewhere down the line I'm going to think "What if".

MAN! Wouldn't it be great to be like Mel Gibson in 'What Women Want'? Reading Woman's minds would sure help.
 

Supradude

Golden Member
Nov 3, 2000
1,727
0
0
i've been in a similar situation before, although when my friend had a BF, i stayed away and did nothing because i think it's wrong to steal gf/bf's from people in relationships,... however, she DID become single again and i ended up pursuing her, but not full-on...

i believe in friendships before relationships and i was very good friends with this girl for like 4 years before,(met her freshman year of HS). so when she became single again i just hung out with her more and talked to her a lot. Helped that she was cool with talkin bout feelings and stuff and so this was during summer so it just prorgressed that we communicated more. being the dork i am and valuing her friendship, i did start to give her hints about my feelings but then i made sure to let her know that her friendship meant a lot to me. when i finally confessed myself and asked her out it was during a dinner and within a sea of metaphors cause i was too shy to say it right out front. (basically, i the conversation said something like, i like you a lot but i want to make sure our friendship never changes if we go out) Long story short, she said yes but we had to part to go to different colleges, after a month or so, we both decided we were better for each other as friends. (i later found out she thought she was being unfair to me cause i was so into the relationship but she was thinking about it and her feelings for me :() ... but to this day we are still very good friends and if nothing even closer than before the relationship...

so i guess what this huge long-winded thread is saying is that relationships can work from a foundation of friendship, and given the right people, circumstance, and careful handling, the relationship can work great and even if it ends, the friendship can go on... :)

good luck to you if you decide to go for it :D

p.s. man i said a lot ... :eek:
 

DannyLove

Lifer
Oct 17, 2000
12,876
4
76
cool, thanks for the input. i just wondered how others took this situation. I obviously can't do anything about mine anymore, but i think its for the best
 

Titicaca

Junior Member
Feb 21, 2001
5
0
0
I'm assuming that this is a different person than the previous situation. If so, i wouldn't judge one by the other. The whole situation depends on the individual person/people involved. I wouldn't say just jump into it, but maybe bring it up in casual conversation with this girl. I guess the idea is to not wait too long, and also not to make a big deal about it and not let the feelings build up to where it will ruin the friendship if the "more-than-friendship" relationship falls through. Then if she says "maybe" or "yes", then you can take things slowly and if she kinda hesitates or says "no thanks" then you hopefully saved yourself weeks or months or torturing yourself wondering.

Good luck man, whatever you decide.

T.