Originally posted by: michaelpatrick33
The OP did state that she has medical bills for her daughter and her hours were cut and the food money is now going to the medical bills. Did you read the OP? Sounds like you are questioning her motivations when the OP made it pretty clear he believes (and knows) she is having problems.
Edit: As a fellow Republican I do find it amusing when people are told to be personally responsible when they are barely scraping by and skipping meals are "get a better job" or "suck it up" or "get more training" or "why are people quick to give HANDOUTS" usually from the middle and upper class perspective (me being straight middle class). The arrogance of non-compassion is more stunning than amusing. Should she get a free ride? No, of course not but reading the OP sure makes it look like she is having a hard time and most importantly of all IS NOT LOOKING OR ASKING FOR A HANDOUT.
I agree with you that she could streamline her budget possibly but since the OP (and other secretaries) see an issue and presumably know she is worth trying to help why not suggest solutions rather than suggest her potential faults.
A raffle for a nice sized gift check that she will win or a pretend survey (with approval from bosses) in which she wins a prize are good solutions. Checking with the boss to see if there can be a raise (if she is a great worker as the OP appears to think) to help offset the loss in overtime is another option.
Of course I read the OP. Does that make my questions any less relevant? If she truly does need help a gift card is like pissing on a forest fire. Her first mistake was budgeting OT into her overall budget. I dont care how much OT/shift diff you get, dont expect it to always be there. You never know when something will come along and strip it away.
Moving on, the point of the questions is to give her MEANINGFUL help. See above about pissing on a forest fire.
She she have an ex-husband? Need child support? Maybe a "drawing" (Rigged of course) for a free 1 hour consultation with an attorney is what she needs.
Does she have nice nails and cable? But still cant afford lunch? Maybe a "drawing" (Rigged of course) for a financial planner is in order to get her a budget.
Otherwise, you can eat cheaply. VERY cheaply. I've been there. I've been homeless and worked up to middle class. The arrogance of my non-compassion comes from first hand experience of seeing people sell their food stamps for booze, from buying steaks and shrimp while I eat Ramen. From driving a ncie shiny car while I have a sh1tbox. Yeah, I dont have much use for the poor getting handouts on MY dime.
Now obviously those examples most likely dont apply to her, but none the less you have to understand her financial picture before just saying "Aww gee, she doesnt eat lunch? Lets help!"
So, I ask again......
What does she drive? Are her nails done? House or apartment? How big? Does she get child support? How many kids? Previous husband?