For those curious about IMAX...

VIAN

Diamond Member
Aug 22, 2003
6,575
1
0
it sucks. Yesterday I went to the Liberty Science Center in New Jersey and saw and IMAX movie. I've always wanted to see one considering how big the screen was. And it was horrible. These are the cons:

It takes up a lot of space.

The picture is so big and you sit too close to the screen that reading text hurts and fast motion can be nauseating. You also have to like turn your heat in all directions, but it's not like you still don't feel like your are in a theatre. The only good thing about the entire screen wasn't the fact that it surrounded you, but that it was huge.

The screen is made up of pieces of screen and you are able to see the divisions during the movie which totally ruins the immersion.

The screen is so big that all the action seems like it's happening on the lower half of the screen while for nice aerial shots of land and vast surfaces it seems to be doing well in but you do have to move your head pretty far up, far from the action and the movement takes you away from the experience.

Seats don't have as much space as traditional theaters and that's not cool for my legs.

Now the biggest issue with IMAX. Inconsistant picture clarity. At the bottom center of the screen it had excellent as you'd expect picture quality. Moving away from the center to the sides, the image starts to curve. Anything straight will now be a bit curvy and it increases as you move further away from the center and almost looks like the image gets stretched near the end of the picture to the side. This doesn't happen when moving away from the center going up however. But other than the curving, you also get magnificent convergence issues as you move away from the center and loss of contrast although, the loss in horrible, I still feel like it's there. And when I mean center, I mean center, about 20 degrees away from the center on either side, the pic starts to curve already.

I had a horrible experience compared to all the hype that was about. IMAX is totally useless and has too many cons to ever be anything special.
 

Matthias99

Diamond Member
Oct 7, 2003
8,808
0
0
Originally posted by: biostud
must be a bad theater, the one I've tried was great.

Same here. I've seen them in multiple theaters, both IMAX and OmniMAX (the wraparound kind; they have these at the Museum Of Science in Boston and the Franklin Institute in Philadelphia, among other places). No convergence issues that I could see.

The screen is made up of pieces of screen and you are able to see the divisions during the movie which totally ruins the immersion.

You *can* see them if you're looking for them (IMO, it's pretty minor), but then again, you can often see dull patches or other flaws in conventional movie screens.

The screen is so big that all the action seems like it's happening on the lower half of the screen while for nice aerial shots of land and vast surfaces it seems to be doing well in but you do have to move your head pretty far up, far from the action and the movement takes you away from the experience.

Wow, a little bit of a run-on sentence there? :p

Some people don't like the very large screen; they get motion sickness, or don't like not being able to focus on the majority of the image at once. That's what you pay for visual immersion; you can't 'focus' on your whole FOV in real life, either. I don't like sitting way down front, though; I *do* think you have to look too far up if you sit that close to the screen.

Seats don't have as much space as traditional theaters and that's not cool for my legs.

I'm 6'6" and have never had a problem in an IMAX theater. Most of them use very steeply raked stadium seating, and legroom is generally fine...
 

Matthias99

Diamond Member
Oct 7, 2003
8,808
0
0
Originally posted by: JonnyBlaze
im going to the one in Boston soon. what movie did you see there?

Actually, lately I've been going to the one at the Providence Place mall (I live near there now). I haven't been to an IMAX movie at the MOS in a *while*... not sure what the last thing I saw there was. The one on the Titanic, maybe?

There's also an IMAX theater at the New England Aquarium. I haven't seen a movie there, though.
 

Merlyn3D

Platinum Member
Sep 15, 2001
2,148
0
0
I've seen a couple mainstream movies (Matrix 2, and Harry Potter) on the IMAX screen at the Sony Metreon in SF, awesome clarity and sound. Seats there have more space than conventional theater.
 

n7

Elite Member
Jan 4, 2004
21,281
4
81
Originally posted by: 49erinnc
Originally posted by: biostud
must be a bad theater, the one I've tried was great.


Yeah same here.

I have been amazed every time i go to see anything in IMAX!

You musta have gotten a bad seat, & a bad theatre.