• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Florida's scientist was fired for refusing to 'manipulate' COVID-19 data

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Isn't this what they want to go to war against China over? For hiding / mismanaging COVID?
Aren't we proven to be doing the exact same things?

Hi, you must be new here. When the GOP, the right, or trump accuse people of something it’s because they themselves are doing it. So when you hear trump say China is fudging the numbers, what he’s really saying is that he is fudging the numbers. It’s their number one go to play.
 
Here's another take on the fired scientist story--she may not have been telling the full truth and it seems she has had issues with authority in the past. Not sure *I* trust the first source, but DeSantis is firing back and perhaps its prudent to wait for the full story to come out:



Let's see if the national media revisits this...
 
Here's another take on the fired scientist story--she may not have been telling the full truth and it seems she has had issues with authority in the past. Not sure *I* trust the first source, but DeSantis is firing back and perhaps its prudent to wait for the full story to come out:



Let's see if the national media revisits this...

I had a funny feeling about this one from the get go. I didn't know about most of what was in that article, except one point in it was readily apparent. Why were they calling her a "scientist" when she has a degree in geography and seems to be acting as a software engineer? It sounded like an attempt to elevate her role.
 
I had a funny feeling about this one from the get go. I didn't know about most of what was in that article, except one point in it was readily apparent. Why were they calling her a "scientist" when she has a degree in geography and seems to be acting as a software engineer? It sounded like an attempt to elevate her role.
Technically she has a PhD related to Geographical Information Systems, which I would assume is an Information Science? But no, she's not a trained epidemiologist or public health official. She essentially was responsible for loading multiple data sets into the ArcGIS tool they were using to visualize said datasets and make them accessible.
 
Absolutely shameful, but something I expected of DeSantis and Florida. I strongly suspect that this is not-by far-the only red state fudging it's numbers for political purposes.
Rebekah Jones a super scientist and software engineer. She builds portals and specializes in epidemiology when not committing felonies. He job duties read more like a data analyst. If the Tampa Bay Times is calling a theory against the GOP a fake, it is Joe Biden getting arrested level of fake.

 
Your Phd is in what field? What crimes is she under investigation for?


From the article:
"Jones also has an extensive criminal history in Leon County, where she’s been arrested and charged with three felonies, including one for robbery, and a handful of misdemeanor cases including “sexual cyberstalking,” a case where she created a website and used it to sexually harass her ex-boyfriend. The website has been taken down, but images from the case exist in Leon County court records.

Most of the charges filed against her came after she was hired by the Department of Health, so they would not have turned up in any background check."

Tell us about your doctorate degree(s).
 
Tell us about your doctorate degree(s).
Again your PhD is in what? I didn’t question her academic credentials you did. So tell us your basis for doing so?

As for the other stuff, yeah that isn’t a good look for her. Your point would have been better made by focusing on that instead of trying to completely tear her down by questioning her education.
 
I have a PhD in chemistry. I sure as shit consider her a scientist.



Not sure I would agree with that. If you get a PhD in computer science or engineering does that mean you are a scientist. Does it mean everyone who gets a PhD is a scientist. A doctorate is the level of learning you have achieved and it depends on what you do with it that determines whether you are considered a scientist. It sounds like from the various stories she used her PhD in GIS to build and manage a web portal to provide data to the public. IMO some of the media are inflating her classification to scientist to make the situation look worse.

Anyway, here is an article that seems balanced. They use the term analyst / manager which i think is more accurate in this case. I do believe DeSantis and his people wanted to make it harder or impossible to download the raw data for people to use their own data analysis process.


Internal emails indicate Jones resisted when her bosses told her to remove the raw data from the website, meaning that users could no longer download it for analysis.

The data had just been downloaded and used by newspapers to report that sickness in Florida emerged as early as January, a fact that led some to second-guess whether DeSantis acted quickly enough to shut down the state.

In a May 4 email from Jones to Department of Health IT Director Craig Curry, she wrote: “I’m not pulling our primary resource for coronavirus data because he wants to stick it to journalists and make them copy and paste from the tables in the pdfs. If it’s in the dashboard, it’s public. Period. There is no way around that.

"We have gained national — no, international — notoriety for being the best state in the country with data transparency. I’m not trashing all of that work and progress because he got asked a few questions by reporters — which I read and were completely fair and legitimate questions that should have been asked.”

It’s not clear who Jones was referring to when she said “he.”

Florida’s coronavirus dashboard has been the state’s main hub for illustrating the pandemic’s impact on Florida.
About two hours later, Curry emailed, telling her that "per Dr. [Carina] Blackmore, disable the ability to export the data to files from the dashboard immediately.”

“This is the wrong call,” Jones responded.

The next morning, Blackmore emailed Jones and Curry to “get the web populated in a way that doesn’t expose the raw data to those who don’t need access.”

Jones, who was GIS manager in the Division of Disease Control and Health Protection, publicized her plight Friday in a mass email to users of the data. She notified everyone that she’d been removed from involvement in the dashboard and that it had been assigned to employees she didn’t think would give it around-the-clock attention.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top