Flip-style Video Vs. P&S Video

JACKHAMMER

Platinum Member
Oct 9, 1999
2,870
0
76
OK, so here's the deal: We had a baby just over a month ago, and documented it through use of our couple year old Panny HD cam (SD5) and our Canon P&S (IS 780). I am pretty happy with the results but realize it is a total PITA to edit the .mts files, etc.

Anyway the in-laws have been talking about getting a camcorder for use with the new baby. The sister in law suggested that we should get them a FLIP because they are easier to use. Now, my in-laws don't even have a digital camera, and avoid the computer like the plague, they use the Walgreen's throw aways. I don't think digital video is for these folks, but I am not about to make that argument. Regardless, here are the two options we are looking at:

With about a $200 budget

1. Buy them a Flip and a cheap digital P&S.
2. Buy them a nicer P&S (something along the lines of my 780) to both shoot video and pics.


Anybody have experience with this type of equipment?
 

gar655

Senior member
Mar 4, 2008
565
0
71
Get them an iPhone 4G. Better video than ANY $200 video camera or P&S camera.
 

speedy2

Golden Member
Nov 30, 2008
1,294
0
71
People like that probably won't enjoy a digital camera. if they don't touch a computer, they're not going to dump photos.

My parents are the same way.

My suggestion, find them a DV Camcorder. For still, find them a cheap used point and shoot. I found a Canon A80 that takes wonderful pics for $30

By the way, I'm even selling my Sony Handycam http://forums.anandtech.com/showthread.php?t=2109577

The Camcorder would allow them to record and play video all in one unit. No need to dump video anywhere. My dad has a Hi8 camcorder. And that's all he does. Stores the tapes just like any old camcorder and he's perfectly happy with it. He's 100% anti computer lol